Imagine being able to chat to a dozen of the world's leading thinkers in marketing and you have `Conversations with Marketing Masters' by Laura Mazur and Louella Miles. They asked gurus from Philip Kotler to Don Schultz about this `sometimes infuriating discipline' and first about their professional histories. Interestingly few had received formal training in marketing. Kotler had been an economist; Regis McKenna a philosopher; Don Peppers an astronautical engineer and Martha Rogers came from a liberal arts background. But a common theme did emerge when they talked about the marketing discipline. They saw the area as having moved from being `devoid of any scientific basis' (Kotler) to where marketing can now be labelled as a technology (McKenna). John Quelch was one of few to suggest a `combination of left and right brain thinking', creativity as well as discipline in being a successful marketer. A picture emerged of the modern marketer as technologist, trained on marketing simulations such as Markstrat from Jean-Claude Larreche. The poor marketer was one constantly adopting new fads and demanding higher budgets.
Most emphasised the need to start with an understanding of the customer with key success factors being relevance to the customer and differentiation (David Aaker). Al Ries and Jack Trout not surprisingly offered similar insights with Ries using Volvo as an example of successful positioning, a car brand associated with safety in customers' minds without necessarily scoring well for safety in the opinion of the insurance industry. Trout emphasised specialisation, `being very very good at one thing and then owning it in the mind of your customers'.
Many were concerned about the future for marketing, wondering where the new ideas were coming from, implying that these were few and far between. Ries pointed to Fortune magazine's decision not to include any marketing books in their choice of the best business books. There were some interesting insights into direct marketing and the use of the Internet from Lester Wunderman but very little comment on the rise of retailer power and what to do about it. There was no contrast between the corporate branding of many retailers in their marketing of own brands with the more expensive marketing models of the consumer brand doyennes of the last millennium.
The book will interest marketing practitioners and academics alike. A good read when you have the time and space to reflect on where marketing has travelled from and where it may be heading.