I deeply sympathize with what Tom Plate was trying to do here. LKY is a great man who has unfairly been maligned and ignored by the Western journalistic establishment. Mr Plate was trying to bring a sympathetic portrait of LKY and his views to Westerners. Unfortunately, he wasn't the man to do it.
The book is the result of a couple of hours worth of interview Mr. Plate conducted with LKY over the course of two days in July of 2009. Unfortunately, Mr. Plate spends too much of the text relaying his thoughts and his end of the conversation. I didn't buy this book to get some Western journalist's views and observations: I want to know what LKY thinks. I don't care what LKY looks like (I can watch him on the Charlie Rose show for that), or how much he coughs, and I found the Irving Berlin "fox or hedgehog" metaphor Plate kept trotting out to be imbecilic and disrespectful. I'm sure Mr. Plate is a nice enough fellow, and it's obvious his heart is in the right place. Unfortunately, despite all his impressive credentials, he wasn't the right person for this job. I don't know who would be these days. Certainly it needs to be someone more culturally conservative than Plate: you don't go asking a modern day Lykurgus what kind of dope he likes to take when he's stressed out. Not only is that not interesting: it simply isn't done by civilized people. Projecting your vices onto others is ... insulting.
While Plate is to be commended for not bothering LKY with the type of nonsense that usually obsesses Western reporters (aka, "why don't you accord more power to unaccountable Western type reporters, so we can make a mess of your country like we did our own?"), he also didn't ask enough interesting questions. What would I have liked are LKY's views on American politics and culture. I'm pretty sure he's thought about it, but nobody is asking him about it. As a citizen of a decaying empire, one which LKY has a selfish interest in preserving, I'd really like to know what he thinks of our problems. Not the silly problems: the big ones -the death of the family, the decline of civic life, corruption, the decline of the political class, the vastly complex politics between the races and interest groups in American society, the problems with immigration and assimilation, our halfwitted class of semi-educated "bohemian bourgeois" -and what about our oligarchs? How did LKY deal with them in his own country, and how did he co-opt his would be Singapura oligarchs towards the good of his society? What would he suggest if Barack Obama asked him for advice .... on any subject. Even a dumb policy nerd issue like Health Care: I'd like to know what LKY thinks, and how he did it in Singapore (yes, their system is superior by any measure, and from what I know about how it works, it will make nobody with a political axe to grind in America happy). Heck, I'd like to know what LKY thinks about the fertility crisis in his country. Since the same disease afflicts the entire civilized world, it might be interesting to know what someone with the LKY brain and honest tongue thinks about such matters. Nope; instead I know what LKY wore on a July afternoon in 2009, that Tom is a mush headed goofball who takes prozac, and that LKY gave Tom a nice hug afterwords. That's just plain weak-sauce. I'm no professor of Journalism, but if you stuck me in the room with someone as interesting as LKY for ... I dunno, 45 minutes, I could come back with more material for a book than this. And you know what? I wouldn't have gotten the Michael Fay date on page 33 wrong either, because I never made my brain into swiss cheese by taking Prozac. Jaybers.
Plate does provide a lot of useful connecting history for people who don't know anything about that part of the world; I suppose those passages were acceptable, but I would expect anyone interested in LKY to know about the opium wars, or the fact that caning was a British invention. Plus, what there is of LKY in here is fascinating and entertaining. As such, it merits a couple of stars above par.