This book is one of a trilogy, which takes you through a first contact experience gone very badly wrong.
The way in which the story unfolds, initially through he eyes of the humans, then in the next book through the eyes of the aliens, clearly has been carefully thought through. In fact, the trilogy's structure challenges you to rethink your views of the aliens and humans alike as you progress from one book to the next. In fact, its hard not to take a firm stance on who's fault the whole mess was in one book and then reverse that stance in the second.
I happened to start on the second book, so initially read the story from the aliens point of view...and i was thinking "tsk..just like humans...pah!", but then as i read the first book i could understand why the humans acted and reacted in the way that they did.
The third book, ties it all together and pretty much everyone lives happily ever after.
The only criticism I would give of this book, is that there is a particular species who seem to be deeply involved in everything, but their motivations are never really explained and civilisation never really explored. It left me thinking...."so why are they doing that? Whats in it for them? Who are these people?"...which pulled me a little out of the story
I guess if i had to give it another criticism, it would be the structure of the story, which ironically for me is also one of its great strengths. What i mean is this. Its very difficult to pick up one of these books and go "oh that was a nice story...but not sure ill bother with the rest of the books".
The problem is, either of the first two books only give one side of half the story...so you arnt given the tools to judge whether the whole story is nice or not. To fully understand the story you definately have to read the first two books. I guess then you can make your mind up on whether you want to read the third and see how it ends...
Mind you...i really enjoyed them all...so what do i care? :)