6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Evertype edition--a careful, properly typeset book worthy of the name "dictionary", 21 July 2009
By Michael Everson "Evertype" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: A Concise Dictionary of Middle English (Hardcover)
At the risk of showing blatent conflict-of-interest, I'm writing this because I noticed that reviews for OTHER publishers' editions (and their ratings) showed up on this listing. I won't belabour this review with self-serving hyperbole. I'll just quote two paragraphs from the introduction:
"Free online digital editions of the dictionary are now available at two major archives, and these too are useful for online searching. Some of these have been edited into legible formats; some are more or less raw ascii texts. A few "publishers" have released printed versions which are little more than dumps of those plain-text files--and I use the scare quotes advisedly here, feeling sorry for those students who have bought those editions thinking that they were, in fact, buying proper dictionaries.
"This edition has been set in Baskerville, a clear and accessible font, which it is hoped, will increase the legibility of the book. Further choices made in typesetting have led to additional changes in format, both for aesthetic reasons and to modernize the text in line with the contemporary reader's expectations."
I trust that potential buyers will take advantage of Amazon's excellent "Look Inside!" feature before making their purchase decisions.
Also available in paperback: A Concise Dictionary of Middle English (Middle English Edition)
6 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Amateurishly typeset, 27 Feb 2008
By David M. Jones - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: A Concise Dictionary of Middle English (Paperback)
The BiblioBazaar edition of "A Concise Dictionary of Middle English" appears to be a poorly typeset copy of the electronic text available from Project Gutenberg (Ebook #10625). BiblioBazaar improved on the Plain Label Books edition by replacing underlined words with italic text, but that seems to be the limit of their effort. For example, instead of using boldface, words are surrounded by tildes (~bold~) and yoghs are represented as "3*", just as in the Gutenberg text.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Evertype edition--a careful, properly typeset book worthy of the name "dictionary", 25 Feb 2011
By Michael Everson "Evertype" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: A Concise Dictionary of Middle English (Paperback)
At the risk of showing blatent conflict-of-interest, I'm writing this because I noticed that reviews for OTHER publishers' editions (and their ratings) showed up on this listing. I won't belabour this review with self-serving hyperbole. I'll just quote two paragraphs from the introduction:
"Free online digital editions of the dictionary are now available at two major archives, and these too are useful for online searching. Some of these have been edited into legible formats; some are more or less raw ascii texts. A few "publishers" have released printed versions which are little more than dumps of those plain-text files--and I use the scare quotes advisedly here, feeling sorry for those students who have bought those editions thinking that they were, in fact, buying proper dictionaries.
"This edition has been set in Baskerville, a clear and accessible font, which it is hoped, will increase the legibility of the book. Further choices made in typesetting have led to additional changes in format, both for aesthetic reasons and to modernize the text in line with the contemporary reader's expectations."
I trust that potential buyers will take advantage of Amazon's excellent "Look Inside!" feature before making their purchase decisions.
Also available in hardcover: A Concise Dictionary of Middle English (Middle English Edition)