I almost cringe at the thought what a great book a good popular historian might have written based on this material. As it is, ms. Moore confines herself to categorizing the contemporary descriptions and comments on the subject and her only other imput is modernising the spelling a bit. Now I'm all for using 18th century quotes sprinkled liberally through the text of a popular history book, liking a good laugh just as much as the next man. But 18th century storytellers and commentators, even the good ones by contemporary standards, tend to come across as long-winded and pompous by 21st century standards. Consequently, what might have been a compelling and highly entertaining read is basically a book that prints out in full what (I think) should have been used as notes and bibliography. No doubt serious students of the period will be pleased to be able to study the original comments and will rate the book much higher than I do. Those who like books on subjects like these to be entertainingly written as well as informative would in my humble opinion be well advised to steer clear.