- Hardcover: 240 pages
- Publisher: Fourth Estate; First Edition, First Impression edition (5 May 2008)
- Language English
- ISBN-10: 0007251149
- ISBN-13: 978-0007251148
- Product Dimensions: 14.1 x 2.6 x 22.2 cm
- Average Customer Review: 3.4 out of 5 stars See all reviews (10 customer reviews)
- Amazon Bestsellers Rank: 545,871 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
Comrade Jim: The Spy Who Played for Spartak
and over one million other books are available for Amazon Kindle .
Learn more
| ||||||||||||||||||||
Did you know you can trade in your old books for an Amazon.co.uk Gift Card to spend on the things you want? Plus, get an extra £5 Gift Certificate when you trade in books worth £10 or more before June 30, 2012. Visit the Books Trade-In Store for more details. |
Product details |
More About the Author
Product Description
Review
'What is most riveting about this very honest book is that his story is so little known and that he has been able to live his life totally on his own terms, whether under Brezhnev or under Blair.’ The Resident
Review
'What is most riveting about this very honest book is that his story is so little known and that he has been able to live his life totally on his own terms, whether under Brezhnev or under Blair.' The Resident
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
18 of 22 people found the following review helpful
Format:Hardcover
Well, what can I say? I first came across his story in a "Guardian" article a couple of years ago. In that version, he played successive matches against Pakhtakor (2-2) and Kairat (1-1) in Moscow. He mentioned that he had to look up the Pakhtakor result as his memory was somewhat hazy. Spartak did indeed play Pakhtakor and Kairat in successive games (2-2 and 1-0) in April 1963; however, these games did not take place in Moscow but in Tashkent and Almaty. The Moscow matches against these sides took place in November (2-0 against Kairat, 4-4 against Pakhtakor (the last game of the season, played in front of just 3 thousand fans)).
Fast-forward 2 years, Riordan's book comes out and... his memory seems to come back! He goes into great detail describing the Pakhtakor match. June 1963. 2-0 down, Reingold scores twice (one a penalty) and the game finishes 2-2. Riordan tells us what goes through his mind during the match. A few weeks later he turns out against Kairat (1-0). He even comes across a brochure a few years ago that lists the line-up as 3-2-5 (let's let it pass as a pictorial representation of W-M) with Eordanov at centre-back. But all this is totally at odds with the events of the 1963 season (or any other season, for that matter)! Even the formation does not stand up to scrutiny as Spartak abandoned W-M during the 1962 season and were mostly using 4-2-4 by 1963 before a poor run of results at the start of that season caused them to revert to W-M for the match against Lokomotiv in June 1963 (with disastrous consequences!) After that Spartak switched to 4-3-3, which again contradicts Riordan's claims.
Finally, he claimes to have replace a "Valery Volkov" in the Spartak side (who was drunk). Who is this player? His name does not appear in any reference material and no older fans remember him!!!
In Russia, Riordan's claims were met with disbelief and ridicule as there is simply nothing to back them up. I could understand Riordan publishing his story, say, 20-30 years ago, when information did not travel so freely across the Iron Curtain but nowadays...
PS Reviews of this book appeared in two established football magazines - "Four Four Two" and "When Saturday Comes". Both reviewers admitted that they did not think it would be necessary to go and look for historical proof for his claims. I also noticed that in "Four Four Two" (168) Jim Riordan is credited with 2 games for Spartak Moscow in the "Brits Abroad" feature. Then I read an frankly inane interview with him in issue 169 where he reiterates his claims. I am completely mystified as to why no one has actually bothered to check whether his story actually survives the most basic of tests - the 1963 Soviet League fixture list.
Fast-forward 2 years, Riordan's book comes out and... his memory seems to come back! He goes into great detail describing the Pakhtakor match. June 1963. 2-0 down, Reingold scores twice (one a penalty) and the game finishes 2-2. Riordan tells us what goes through his mind during the match. A few weeks later he turns out against Kairat (1-0). He even comes across a brochure a few years ago that lists the line-up as 3-2-5 (let's let it pass as a pictorial representation of W-M) with Eordanov at centre-back. But all this is totally at odds with the events of the 1963 season (or any other season, for that matter)! Even the formation does not stand up to scrutiny as Spartak abandoned W-M during the 1962 season and were mostly using 4-2-4 by 1963 before a poor run of results at the start of that season caused them to revert to W-M for the match against Lokomotiv in June 1963 (with disastrous consequences!) After that Spartak switched to 4-3-3, which again contradicts Riordan's claims.
Finally, he claimes to have replace a "Valery Volkov" in the Spartak side (who was drunk). Who is this player? His name does not appear in any reference material and no older fans remember him!!!
In Russia, Riordan's claims were met with disbelief and ridicule as there is simply nothing to back them up. I could understand Riordan publishing his story, say, 20-30 years ago, when information did not travel so freely across the Iron Curtain but nowadays...
PS Reviews of this book appeared in two established football magazines - "Four Four Two" and "When Saturday Comes". Both reviewers admitted that they did not think it would be necessary to go and look for historical proof for his claims. I also noticed that in "Four Four Two" (168) Jim Riordan is credited with 2 games for Spartak Moscow in the "Brits Abroad" feature. Then I read an frankly inane interview with him in issue 169 where he reiterates his claims. I am completely mystified as to why no one has actually bothered to check whether his story actually survives the most basic of tests - the 1963 Soviet League fixture list.
8 of 10 people found the following review helpful
Format:Hardcover
Why were they taken down? Was this done before or after I wrote to the publisher in early December? I will post my original comment once again (sent to the publisher, receiving no response):
"Well, what can I say? I first came across his story in a "Guardian"
article a couple of years ago. In that version, he played successive
matches against Pakhtakor (2-2) and Kairat (1-1) in Moscow. He mentioned
that he had to look up the Pakhtakor result as his memory was somewhat
hazy. Spartak did indeed play Pakhtakor and Kairat in successive games
(2-2 and 1-0) in April 1963; however, these games did not take place in
Moscow but in Tashkent and Almaty. The Moscow matches against these
sides took place in November (2-0 against Kairat, 4-4 against Pakhtakor
(the last game of the season, played in front of just 3 thousand fans)).
Fast-forward 2 years, Riordan's book comes out and... his memory seems
to come back! He goes into great detail describing the Pakhtakor match.
June 1963. 2-0 down, Reingold scores twice (one a penalty) and the game
finishes 2-2. Riordan tells us what goes through his mind during the
match. A few weeks later he turns out against Kairat (1-0). He even
comes across a brochure a few years ago that lists the line-up as 3-2-5
(let's let it pass as a pictorial representation of W-M) with Eordanov
at centre-back. But all this is totally at odds with the events of the
1963 season (or any other season, for that matter)! Even the formation
does not stand up to scrutiny as Spartak abandoned W-M during the 1962
season and were mostly using 4-2-4 by 1963 before a poor run of results
at the start of that season caused them to revert to W-M for the match
against Lokomotiv in June 1963 (with disastrous consequences!) After
that Spartak switched to 4-3-3, which again contradicts Riordan's
claims.
Finally, he claimes to have replace a "Valery Volkov" in the Spartak
side (who was drunk). Who is this player? His name does not appear in
any reference material and no older fans remember him!!!
In Russia, Riordan's claims were met with disbelief and ridicule as
there is simply nothing to back them up. I could understand Riordan
publishing his story, say, 20-30 years ago, when information did not
travel so freely across the Iron Curtain but nowadays...
PS Reviews of this book appeared in two established football magazines -
"Four Four Two" and "When Saturday Comes". Both reviewers admitted that
they did not think it would be necessary to go and look for historical
proof for his claims (as presumably it's something for the publisher to do). I also noticed that in "Four Four Two" (168) Jim
Riordan is credited with 2 games for Spartak Moscow in the "Brits
Abroad" feature. Then I read an frankly inane interview with him in
issue 169 where he reiterates his claims. I am completely mystified as
to why no one has actually bothered to check whether his story actually
survives the most basic of tests - the 1963 Soviet League fixture list."
"Well, what can I say? I first came across his story in a "Guardian"
article a couple of years ago. In that version, he played successive
matches against Pakhtakor (2-2) and Kairat (1-1) in Moscow. He mentioned
that he had to look up the Pakhtakor result as his memory was somewhat
hazy. Spartak did indeed play Pakhtakor and Kairat in successive games
(2-2 and 1-0) in April 1963; however, these games did not take place in
Moscow but in Tashkent and Almaty. The Moscow matches against these
sides took place in November (2-0 against Kairat, 4-4 against Pakhtakor
(the last game of the season, played in front of just 3 thousand fans)).
Fast-forward 2 years, Riordan's book comes out and... his memory seems
to come back! He goes into great detail describing the Pakhtakor match.
June 1963. 2-0 down, Reingold scores twice (one a penalty) and the game
finishes 2-2. Riordan tells us what goes through his mind during the
match. A few weeks later he turns out against Kairat (1-0). He even
comes across a brochure a few years ago that lists the line-up as 3-2-5
(let's let it pass as a pictorial representation of W-M) with Eordanov
at centre-back. But all this is totally at odds with the events of the
1963 season (or any other season, for that matter)! Even the formation
does not stand up to scrutiny as Spartak abandoned W-M during the 1962
season and were mostly using 4-2-4 by 1963 before a poor run of results
at the start of that season caused them to revert to W-M for the match
against Lokomotiv in June 1963 (with disastrous consequences!) After
that Spartak switched to 4-3-3, which again contradicts Riordan's
claims.
Finally, he claimes to have replace a "Valery Volkov" in the Spartak
side (who was drunk). Who is this player? His name does not appear in
any reference material and no older fans remember him!!!
In Russia, Riordan's claims were met with disbelief and ridicule as
there is simply nothing to back them up. I could understand Riordan
publishing his story, say, 20-30 years ago, when information did not
travel so freely across the Iron Curtain but nowadays...
PS Reviews of this book appeared in two established football magazines -
"Four Four Two" and "When Saturday Comes". Both reviewers admitted that
they did not think it would be necessary to go and look for historical
proof for his claims (as presumably it's something for the publisher to do). I also noticed that in "Four Four Two" (168) Jim
Riordan is credited with 2 games for Spartak Moscow in the "Brits
Abroad" feature. Then I read an frankly inane interview with him in
issue 169 where he reiterates his claims. I am completely mystified as
to why no one has actually bothered to check whether his story actually
survives the most basic of tests - the 1963 Soviet League fixture list."
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful
Format:Hardcover
I was electrified when i just noticed this book and immediately scooped it.
The story seemed so interesting that I couldn't sit still until i passed the book to my English teacher, who was in football business those days (never a pro himself but was through youth squads of 50-s/60-s and therefore retained many connections with the guys who actually made it into the first teams of Moscow based Soviet Premiership clubs). Of course he was an avid football fan and a staunch supporter of preciesely Spartak Moscow.
His immediate reaction after reading this opus was bewilderment. He never encountered any Riordan or Jordanov playing in starting XI or coming in as sub. Moreover factual errors were of extraordinary brazen character. Like pointed out in another review the man confused the venue at which the game took place: Tashkent (now in Uzbekistan) for Moscow which are 1 700 miles apart (according to Google Earth), let alone climatic and geographical differences which are still evident even to a blindman.
This and other glaring inconsistencies forced him to give a call to pro players, then active, and ask for clarification. No one could remember such player. And to conceal such a player would be harder than hide the proverbial needle in a haystack. Just so you know: there were few players of foreign origin (f.e. Spaniards - kids of Spanish Reds - evacuated in the wake of the Spanish Civil War to USSR) in Soviet Championship those years. And everyone remembers their presence nowadays albeit not always their names.
And no one even remebers a Briton, if you don't trust official statistics. Sorry. Nothing personal. But please don't sell a fiction for a real story.
If he was a real player it would be trumpeted all over as triumph of Communist sport's attractiveness over "sweat-extracting" professional sport of "rotting West".
The story seemed so interesting that I couldn't sit still until i passed the book to my English teacher, who was in football business those days (never a pro himself but was through youth squads of 50-s/60-s and therefore retained many connections with the guys who actually made it into the first teams of Moscow based Soviet Premiership clubs). Of course he was an avid football fan and a staunch supporter of preciesely Spartak Moscow.
His immediate reaction after reading this opus was bewilderment. He never encountered any Riordan or Jordanov playing in starting XI or coming in as sub. Moreover factual errors were of extraordinary brazen character. Like pointed out in another review the man confused the venue at which the game took place: Tashkent (now in Uzbekistan) for Moscow which are 1 700 miles apart (according to Google Earth), let alone climatic and geographical differences which are still evident even to a blindman.
This and other glaring inconsistencies forced him to give a call to pro players, then active, and ask for clarification. No one could remember such player. And to conceal such a player would be harder than hide the proverbial needle in a haystack. Just so you know: there were few players of foreign origin (f.e. Spaniards - kids of Spanish Reds - evacuated in the wake of the Spanish Civil War to USSR) in Soviet Championship those years. And everyone remembers their presence nowadays albeit not always their names.
And no one even remebers a Briton, if you don't trust official statistics. Sorry. Nothing personal. But please don't sell a fiction for a real story.
If he was a real player it would be trumpeted all over as triumph of Communist sport's attractiveness over "sweat-extracting" professional sport of "rotting West".
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
Were these reviews helpful?
Let us know
Most Recent Customer Reviews
Lenin of the Rovers
A neglected masterpiece. Jim Riordan died recently and maybe he'll enjoy a little posthumous attention? This is brilliantly written. Read more
Published 1 month ago by Ben Trovato
"...the Truth must have a bodyguard of lies" (W.S. Churchill)
I have had the advantage of having read the other reviews on Amazon, most of which seem to doubt the truth of some of the alleged facts contained in this book. Read more
Published 17 months ago by Ian Millard
Lucky Jim! How I envy him!
An interesting story, written in an 'easy to read' style.
How a young lad, from an ordinary, working-class background, can achieve both academic success and, in the... Read more
How a young lad, from an ordinary, working-class background, can achieve both academic success and, in the... Read more
Published on 7 April 2010 by Chip
Photos?
A very odd book. It contains photographs of Riordan all over Moscow, meeting Yashin, standing in the street, kicking a ball around near Spartak's stadium, but not one photograph of... Read more
Published on 7 July 2008 by Kharms
He taught me at College
Back in the day, Jim was a lecturer who taught me Russian Politics at college. Maybe he still teaches. Read more
Published on 30 May 2008 by Gavino
More than it says on the tin...
This is an amazing story whose title, to be honest, does not do justice to the breadth of experience contained within its pages. Read more
Published on 20 May 2008 by Pompey 54
comrade jim
What a life, what a story! Jim Riordan doesn't so much wander into an unlikely adventure but fall, like Alice down the rabbit hole, into the topsy turvy land of the Red King. Read more
Published on 7 May 2008 by Bella Krik
Customer Discussions
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/02/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192198663_.gif){kind=small}
Listmania!
|
|
Look for similar items by category
- Books > Biography > Political > Britain
- Books > Biography > Political > Countries & Regions > Europe
- Books > Biography > Political > Countries & Regions > Russia
- Books > Biography > Sport > Football
- Books > Biography > True Crime
- Books > Biography > War & Espionage > Espionage
- Books > Poetry, Drama & Criticism > Drama
- Books > Society, Politics & Philosophy > Social Sciences > Social Issues > Football
- Books > Sports, Hobbies & Games > Football > Football Fans
Look for similar items by subject
Feedback
- Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
- I am the Author, and I want to comment on my book.
- I am the Publisher, and I want to comment on this book.
