Most Helpful Customer Reviews
22 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Awe-inspiring! Foreword by Daniel V. Oppenheim, 28 Mar 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Composing Music with Computers (Music Technology) (Paperback)
Composing music with computers is gradually taking its place alongside more traditional ways, such as pencil and paper or improvisation. Computer music is now finding its way into many musical genres, including pop, rock, techno, disco, jazz, and music for film. It is no longer confined to the aesthetics that emerged in the 60s and 70s from the experimental works of Electronic, Acousmatic and Musique Concrète. Gone are the days where computer-aided composition could only be carried out in select institutions using equipment far too expensive for any individual to own. The soundcard, now a standard component in most home computers, outperforms systems that were state-of-the-art a mere 10-15 years ago. Current processor speeds enable real-time synthesis and sound processing even on laptop computers. Consumer music software facilitates musical composition through relatively easy-to-use graphical user-interfaces that require no programming skills. What more could one want? Electroacoustic music in its first few decades inspired a somewhat romantic belief that the new technology, by enabling new sounds and compositional process, would in turn lead to a new music with new concepts, aesthetics, and musical experiences. It is not clear whether this has actually occurred, and if so, to what extent. It seems that the second half of the 20th century, particularly with the move from using analog devices to digital systems, was occupied largely with problems of ?computation technology?, i.e. how to compute music samples fast enough and with good audio quality. There is yet much to be learned about how the computer can help us to express and capture our musical ideas, to experiment with and develop them, and most importantly, to organize them and produce the finished work of art. This problem could be summarized in much simpler words: how to compose music with computers. Consumer applications for musical composition still leave much to be desired. Sequencers, which are so popular for musical composition, model a multi-track recorder that is familiar from the recording studio. This familiarity makes them easy to use but provides little support for the varied musical concepts through which the composer may be conceiving his work. In addition this model emphasizes the placing of musical content in time but doesn?t directly support generation of musical materials. Music is a complex and abstract domain and is inherently subjective. This subjectivity expresses itself in a multitude of different concepts and approaches. Traditional music theory, which developed through vocal and instrumental music over several centuries, has provided many concepts that form the building blocks of musical thought. Note and melody to phrase, motif, development, and structure; tension, and relaxation, to voice leading, counterpoint, harmony, and form?are but a few. Newer musical forms introduced yet other ways of looking at music. The electroacoustic music of the 60s and 70s, made possible for the first time by analog devices and digital computers, encouraged composers to think differently not only about music and the process of composition but also about the sensation of the musical experience. Electronic music built upon concepts derived from Music Serialism and produced musical complexity beyond the ability of human performance. On the other extreme, Musique Concrète led composers to explore timbre, textures, time flow, transitions, phase shifts, and sound morphs. In short, it is clear that different people think about their music using different concepts. Some of these concepts are more general and to some degree universal, but many are highly individualized and apply only to the musical world of a specific composition. The important contribution of this book lies in its in-depth survey of the varied approaches and techniques that have been developed and utilized for generating music with computers in the academic community. Each technique represents a different way of thinking about music. With a little imagination the reader may find that a certain technique can map nicely to his unique way of thinking about music. The tools described in this book can be used to not only to express and generate new musical ideas but also to process previously composed musical materials. More importantly, the reader can experiment hands-on with each technique through a collection of music applications on the accompanying CD-ROM that have been developed by leading researchers in the field. The reader will benefit if he keeps in mind several fundamental questions that Eduardo Miranda raises. Is there a difference between instrumental and computer music? Is there a difference in the way one composes a work for instruments or for computer? Is there a different creative workflow when using pencil and paper, the computer, or improvisational techniques? These questions are especially relevant today where computers equally support the composition of traditional and experimental forms of music. The reader may not find a single decisive answer to these questions, but more aptly, many different answers depending on the person who is asking and the specific musical problem he is considering. This book is applicable whether the reader thinks about his music using traditional concepts or through individualized concepts that apply only in his own particular musical world. This book is also relevant whether the reader is concerned with manipulating the overall structure of his work or with refining minute details. It is highly likely that anyone interested in using computers to compose music will find herein a useful technique, regardless of his style or method of composition. In the tradition of computer music?experiment: try, listen, and refine.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
It does what it says on the tin!!, 9 July 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Composing Music with Computers (Music Technology) (Paperback)
As a DJ I need to know what's coming up before it hits the circuit, so I was well impressed with this book - although I've got a fairly strong programming base, the way Eduardo Reck Miranda introduced and explained the mechanics filled in the gaps without sending me to sleep.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best intro to the techniques of algorithmic composing, 15 Dec 2005
By calvinnme - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Composing Music with Computers (Music Technology) (Paperback)
This book is relevant to several different audiences including computer scientists, mathematicians, and AI researchers. However, this book is most directly aimed at musicians/composers who are interested in algorithmic composition. The book artfully introduces computer science and mathematics concepts to those with music backgrounds, and then also explains some music concepts to those with a more technical background. Some composers will never have a need to compose algorithmically, no matter which tools they have, and others will see immediately how to employ algorithms in their work. For those in the middle,Composing Music with Computers is an essential guide. That said, the book may have been even more valuable to such readers with a greater range of worked-out examples.
Throughout the body of the text,there are helpful illustrations with musical material provided at every appropriate juncture. These illustrations tend to be short and didactic, however, rather than elaborated and evocative.The most useful bridge between theory and practice is provided by chapter 7, a group of three case studies showing in greater detail how musical material can be derived from algorithmic techniques. In particular, the case study, titled "From content to form", shows how to generate chordal material using a collection of generative modules and then to shape that material with a group of "moulding rules". For example, Moulding Rule Two states that '"all ascending sequences. . . of notes are slurred in order to form an articulatory unit". At the end of the discussion is a measure of music for six instruments, complete with articulations, that clearly demonstrates the musical potential of the formalizations that are the subject of the book.
Beyond that, the accompanying CD-ROM includes many applications for algorithmic composition in full-blown or demonstration versions. These include Roger Dannenberg's Nyquist language, the OpenMusic programming system developed by Gérard Assayag and Carlos Agon at IRCAM, a prototype of Music Sketcher, an algorithmic composition tool designed by Daniel Oppenheim and his colleagues at the IBM Computer Music Center, and several others. There are entries for both Windows and Macintosh platforms, with documentation and supporting material. The CDROM alone makes the book well worth the investment for a serious study of algorithmic composition. With this toolbox, readers can immediately test their ideas using established and relevant software.
This book addresses a field that is widely practiced but little described: probably the closest equivalent is Phil Winsor's "Automated Music Composition", published in 1989. Not only is the book needed, but it is exceptionally well-written and, above all, clear. Composers, student or otherwise, will find a valuable resource for ideas, software, algorithms, and their underlying mathematics. This lucid and scholarly text will be read not only by computer musicians, but by everyone with an interest in the artistic possibilities of technology.
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A great learning experience, 6 Aug 2001
By David Byrne - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Composing Music with Computers (Music Technology) (Paperback)
I am neither a musician or a computer programmer by trade but have a strong interest in both topics. I have been looking for just this type of book for a couple of years now. It provides an excellent balance of detail and overview and seems to cover more maths in an interesting way than I have seen before. It provides a couple of good case studies which are reasonably easy to follow and before I knew I was up and running with my own generated tunes. I haven't even started on the CD yet!
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Demystifies computer-generated music, 14 July 2001
By Brian M - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Composing Music with Computers (Music Technology) (Paperback)
I always had problems getting to grips with the math behind computer music. This the first book I found which talks you through comprehensibly. There are loads of diagrams and helpful examples. Hasn't made it to the shelf since I bought it!
|
|
|