As a structurer on commodity markets I must agree that this is not a book for quantitative analysts. Dr. Douglas R. Mclean is certainly disappointed, but this was not a book for him. I must say that the mistakes are really there and this is quite disappointing: for that reason I only give it 4 stars.
Having said that, this book is a reference for anyone working on commodities. I have not found any book that is as complete and insightful as this one.
The first 2 chapters give some notions on market fundamentals such as spot forward and futures markets and their relationships, these are quite important to understand on commodities markets.
The chapters 3 to 6 are about stochastic price modeling, option pricing and risk neutral concepts. These are not my favourite chapters as they are quite technical, and requires some advanced mathematical knowledge, which I have: but it was not the funniest part!
The following chapters - the core value of the book - presents various commodities and their market with unequaled insight. This chapters are essentials for people working on commodities and are useful to novice to learn and experienced financiers to remember. You'll get familiar with the commodities, their characteristics and how they impact their market and price movements.
It is difficult for me to make a review good enough to describe how useful this book is, but as a junior structurer on commodities it really helped me get insight and start with my new job.