Any collector of contemporary art should buy this one. Adam Lindeman has done a superb job of pulling together commentary from many of those who are generally recognized as among today's most influential curators, dealers, collectors and critics. We rarely get to hear from many of these people, yet their consensus is what makes the art market and, for those of us who have been observers for many years, that consensus is sometimes difficult to understand.
There are just enough pictures of works, all in color, to provide a backdrop to what is largely a book devoted to a monologue by each expert. Obviously a curator may have a different viewpoint from a dealer; collectors and critics offer further insights. Reading what each has to say from their various perspectives allows us to reach our own, more informed conclusions.
Would be a five-star rating but the format appears to be a standard list of questions submitted to each respondent with the answers then edited by Lindeman to fit the available space. An interactive format between author and respondent would have allowed some needed follow-up. We also don't hear from art world figures who were most signficant ten years ago, or, in a similar effort twenty years ago, de Coppet's The Art Dealers. The perspectives of those interviewed in de Coppet's book regarding today's art scene would be interesting.
One can hardly talk about collecting today without talking about valuations, and we note that several of Lindeman's participants question the prices currently being paid at auction for some younger artists, such as a million dollars for a Yuskavage when the same money will buy you a strong Close; more for a Glenn Brown than for the Frank Auerbach from which it is derived. The reader is left to reach his or her own conclusions. Still, you have to wonder, given the observations of several figures in the book that you can look at a 20-year old issue of ArtNews and you will not have heard of most of the artists featured: what are the various motivations of those "collecting contemporary" today?