First off, I'm a 20-year-old-guy, probably not the target audience of the minx line of comics, but I'd heard alot of buzz from the states and thought I'd check 'em out, and clubbing just happened to be the first one i picked up.
The art was the first thing that drew me to this book, reminding me of a batman cartoon i used to love as a kid (can't remember which one, but anyway). The drawings are nice and simple; not too cluttered, nice clean graphic style, infact i enjoyed the art very much (despite being alittle amateurish in places) but i do have one major beef; aren't these books supposed to be aimed at teen girls fed-up with the superhero visuals?! dear lord, some of the shots in this book made me embarassed to be reading it in public! But if you can ignore this, the art is quite good ('though noticably drops off towards the end).
Next, the storyline. I enjoyed the begining quite abit; ok, so 'lotte' is anoying at first, and i had to suspend my diselief at the stuff she got away with, it's quite an interesting story that doesn't rush, until about 3 quarters of the way in, then suddenly it takes a supernatural twist and it hurtles forward like an out-of-control mine-cart. When i re-read this book now, i actually stop as soon as the supernatural elements're introduced, because the good stuff's over.
So in short, if you want to give minx a try, I'd reccommend re-gifters first, but if you enjoy that you may get alil something out of this. Although definately flawed, i would reccommend borowing this, but for a cheap thrill it might be worth a flutter.