I would agree wholeheartedly with the reviewers who say this is a good atlas - it's an excellent atlas, with loads of detail, and every little road and hamlet shown. It's also of interest to all drivers, as everyone benefits from this scale.
The problem is the index. Example: I was trying to find Alford in Aberdeenshire. The place wasn't on the page specified. Then I noticed that both Alford, Somerset, and Alford, Lincolnshire, were described in the index as being on the same page (page 2) - and that page was one of Cornwall! In other words, the index can't be relied upon.
I love this atlas, but I always make sure that I find places of interest, or destinaions, in some other way.