What I found was an interesting tale that had a vibrancy of its own, had big fight scenes and brought some new villains to the fore, the Clockwork Vampires. It was fast paced and above all the plot was pretty smooth, however once you take that into consideration though it starts to fall apart as my major gripe (and one that I think a lot of genre fans will recognise) was that the principle cast member is very similar if not a carbon copy of Gemmell's Druss the Legend.
Which, whilst could be seen as a "homage" to the sadly lamented King of British Heroic Fantasy, it did keep coming back to me that the principle character wasn't as fresh or vibrant as David's and sadly lacked what I had come to expect with this type of book. Had Andy changed the character enough to make it his own would have made the book something special instead of something that blends in with the other multitude fantasy fare on the market.