Frequently Bought Together
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Product details
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful
Amazon Verified Purchase
I have a problem with Dickens: his characters are too Manichean, either wholly good or wholly bad. The same can be said for this collection of British movies based on adaptations of his works, but in this instance all three movies are (almost) wholly good. The DVD set was initially purchased by me primarily for my collection of Dirk Bogarde movies, but having watched all three films more than twice, I conclude that this is a fantastic selection. Each film (using the Amazon criteria) merits four stars, but in this instance the whole is greater than the parts and merits five.
The oldest feature here is David Lean's `Great Expectations' of 1946 in its BFI restoration. It has a fantastically atmospheric production design. Its only misfortune for me is that I had already seen Charlotte Rampling play Miss Havisham: anyone else playing this role is going to be an anticlimax. For this disc, the only extra worth listing is the stills gallery.
David Lean repeated his Dickens triumph two years later with probably the most renowned `Oliver twist' ever seen on film. Another BFI restoration, its opening shots of extreme weather and his brilliant use of dramatic shadows makes the film a masterpiece of its day. The extras include a contemporary casting appeal by Tony Wager (who played the young Pip in `Great Expectations'); some good production stills; and a twenty-four-minute documentary from 2000 in which various members of the production crew provide some background information. (It's a shame the late John Howard Davies does not appear.)
`A Tale of Two Cities' of 1958 was directed by Ralph Thomas. In his biography of Bogarde, John Coldstream described the star's part as Sydney Carton as one of those that boosted his sex appeal, "that transformed him from `put to bed' to `take to bed'." There are, though, problems with this film that cannot be gone into here, but it is nevertheless imaginatively put together. Thomas apparently deliberately shot it in black and white, but I wonder if the 4:3 screen ratio is original: there is no reference to this being a BFI restoration. Anyway, the disc comes with written biographies of Bogarde, Thomas, and Dorothy Tutin; lots of excellent still shots taken behind-the-scenes; and another twenty-four-minute documentary from 2000 in which Thomas, Tutin, and Christopher Lee appear.
All in all this is a fantastic selection that is entertaining on so many levels and is equally good value for money for any student of the cinema.
The oldest feature here is David Lean's `Great Expectations' of 1946 in its BFI restoration. It has a fantastically atmospheric production design. Its only misfortune for me is that I had already seen Charlotte Rampling play Miss Havisham: anyone else playing this role is going to be an anticlimax. For this disc, the only extra worth listing is the stills gallery.
David Lean repeated his Dickens triumph two years later with probably the most renowned `Oliver twist' ever seen on film. Another BFI restoration, its opening shots of extreme weather and his brilliant use of dramatic shadows makes the film a masterpiece of its day. The extras include a contemporary casting appeal by Tony Wager (who played the young Pip in `Great Expectations'); some good production stills; and a twenty-four-minute documentary from 2000 in which various members of the production crew provide some background information. (It's a shame the late John Howard Davies does not appear.)
`A Tale of Two Cities' of 1958 was directed by Ralph Thomas. In his biography of Bogarde, John Coldstream described the star's part as Sydney Carton as one of those that boosted his sex appeal, "that transformed him from `put to bed' to `take to bed'." There are, though, problems with this film that cannot be gone into here, but it is nevertheless imaginatively put together. Thomas apparently deliberately shot it in black and white, but I wonder if the 4:3 screen ratio is original: there is no reference to this being a BFI restoration. Anyway, the disc comes with written biographies of Bogarde, Thomas, and Dorothy Tutin; lots of excellent still shots taken behind-the-scenes; and another twenty-four-minute documentary from 2000 in which Thomas, Tutin, and Christopher Lee appear.
All in all this is a fantastic selection that is entertaining on so many levels and is equally good value for money for any student of the cinema.
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful
Amazon Verified Purchase
I saw this edition of Great Expectations first when I was 10 and have never forgotten it. Now in my 70's I found that the young Pip, Estelle and the frissons of fear of meeting the convict in the graveyard, hadnt lost anything with the passage of time, also the slight deception of the older Pip & Estelle who lacked the magic of their childhood versions. Jo was one of the most superbly acted parts, his simple dignity evokes a little tear of sympathy. The print was as clear as a bell. Oliver Twist was good too, Alec Guiness an excellent Fabian (he was also superb as the pale young gentleman in Great Expectations). This a grimmer story tho with a happy ending. I loved seeing both. Havnt seen the third yet.
28 of 30 people found the following review helpful
This remarkable collection of films was a bargain price-wise but artistically also. Nobody forgets in GE - Magwitch launching himself at the inncoent Pip in the graveyard, or in fact the juvenile reply regarding his brother's and sisters - lying in a little row. Acting and direction of the highest quality indeed and this carries over to 'Two cities' as well. True, Bogarde was to go on to become one of Europe's most enduring talents and was perhaps still afflicted by matinee status during this film, but the energy and focus are already apparent, almost nonchalantly deployed. Oliver Twist of course just grabs you in the heart and even has the butchest of us fending off the odd tear. Highly recommended brilliant direction from the legendary David Lean makes this a not to be missed collection.
Most Recent Customer Reviews
Excellent service
What great value to have three such marvellous classic films on one DVD. I bought it for my French neighbour who loves Great Expectations and just hope she can manage without... Read more
Published 18 days ago by A. Hodgson
classic films
Just right for a lazy afternoon's viewing when it's raining and cold outside, curled up on the settee with a cup of coffee.
Published 1 month ago by Dympna M. Kelly
good one
it is a real classic collection.
Three movies in one box.. I would recommend it to
all classic lovers.. give stars as my rating...
Three movies in one box.. I would recommend it to
all classic lovers.. give stars as my rating...
Published 9 months ago by GOPAKUMAR GOPINADHAN PILLAI
Classic Dickens films
An outstanding collection of 3 classic British films of Dickens stories. David Lean's Great Expectations starring Sir John Mills, and featuring Alec Guinness, Finlay Currie and a... Read more
Published 10 months ago by Adder
Tale of Two Cities is not widescreen
It should be noted that "A Tale of Two Cities" ist not in its original aspect ratio, but in 4:3. The trailer is about 1,66:1, and in several scenes of the movie the outmost left... Read more
Published 10 months ago by WESS
What the Dickens
If you are a lover of old classics, then this is a truly great classic triple value pack. My only comment is that these didn't have foreign subtitles which wasn't clear in the... Read more
Published 12 months ago by Angelique
Bargain Classics
Three extremely well made British films at a bargain price. The films are from a golden age of British cinema and stand up well to their modern counterparts.
Published on 3 May 2010 by Mr. D. J. Linnell
Just great films
Three REAL classics in one set worthy of inclusion in anyone's DVD collection and at a great Amazon price
Published on 21 April 2010 by Aremess
Great British Classics!
PLEASE NOTE: THIS REVIEW REFERS TO 'A TALE OF TWO CITIES ONLY':
Great British adaptation of this wonderful story based on the Charles Dickens novel of the same... Read more
Great British adaptation of this wonderful story based on the Charles Dickens novel of the same... Read more
Published on 17 Sep 2008 by FAMOUS NAME
Customer Discussions
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
Listmania!
Look for similar items by subject
Feedback
- Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
