As a setting for alternate history tales, no event has been so thoroughly utilized as the Second World War. With so many books and short stories premised on different outcomes for the conflict, it is unusual to find a work with a fresh approach. In this respect, Leo Rutman's novel stands out from the pack. Taking a German invasion of Britain as his starting point, he goes a step further by imagining a follow-up assault on the United States and a hypothetical conquest of the Northeast. This sets the conditions for the premise of his novel, that of a German occupation of New York City in 1941. With the Wehrmacht parading down Fifth Avenue, Rutman's New Yorkers face life under Nazi control.
Rutman examines the consequences of this occupation through the lives of eight people. Though fictional, some of them are clearly based on contemporary figures. What emerges in these pages is the story of a city coping with the consequences of defeat. Though the Germans seek a "model" occupation akin to that of Paris, the heavy hand of Nazi control soon tightens its grip upon the city. The atmosphere is tense and grim, as spies, collaborators, and mobsters respond in a number of ways, all human and believable. Though fans seeking a larger account of an alternate Second World War may be disappointed by the limited scope of Rutman's work, the author succeeds in presenting an enjoyable tale of suspense and action in a world that might have been.