|
148 of 149 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A useful guide, but the game comes with a good manual, 11 Nov 2005
I bought this guide at the same time as I bought the game it covers as the Civilization series has always been a complex and deep one that rewards time invested understanding how the internal workings of the game are structured and how to handle strategy and yet pervious versions have had dissapointing (or no) printed manuals.The guide is good and it definately adds some more insights to the game, however you should be aware that the manual that comes in the game box is actually a very good one which includes perhaps 70% of the same material found in the guide. So, I would not say I regret having bought the guide but it might be worth buying the game on its own first, reading through and digesting the thick manual and then considering whether or not to buy the guide as well. Things that are in the guide that are not in the manual (or covered in more depth or from a different angle in the guide) include: - a nice summary of differences from Civ 3 for existing players - a slightly more in-depth review of the new civics options with recommendations of good sets of choices to make to achieve various aims - an outline of variant stratgies (e.g. castle, dagger) that is a good introduction - ten pages of a two player game with the two players comments on progress which is rather weak - an excellent summary of the leaders and their strengths and weaknesses which pointed me to the Spanish as a good choice that I would have probably overlooked - a nice overview of some key technologies and how they fit with the game - a good summary of some patterns of building and technology discovering to get you off to the right foot when starting a game - a good overview of key wonders, when to build them and how to use them Hmmm, on reflection I've just gone back and changed my rating to four stars. On balance, I would say that most of this material will appear on fansites pretty quickly as it did for previous versions of Civ and stick to my advice of getting the game and reading the manual before buying this guide. But, if you are the sort of person who likes to have additional strategy guide information in printed form and you feel the manual is lacking in some of the areas I highlight above then this guide will be a useful and good value complement to the thick booklet that comes with the game.
|