Civil War HC [Hardcover]

 

 

Create your own review

THE GOOD: Civil War wasn't outstanding as an event mini-series. But it punched in all the right places and probably had the biggest impact of any Marvel event since the first Secret Wars. There have been those who have complained about characters acting out of... well... character... but if you read all the tie-ins, read Mark Millar's explanations in the extras in this volume and maybe ligten up a bit and stop taking it all so seriously, you'll see that the way it plays out does kind've make sense.

THE BAD: Yes, it feels a little clumsy at times, but it's shameless in what it sets out to do: Create genuine change in the Marvel Universe and tell a mindless blockbuster of a story, which it does. Yes there's some political allegory, but just try to ignore it. The art is sometimes a little stiff and it's impossible not to notice Steve McNiven's obsession with lady-butts.

MORE THAN HALF A BOOK OF EXTRAS: The hardcover edition is probably 40% Civil War and 60% extras. While this doesn't seem like a selling point, the extras are really interesting in terms of understanding the creative process, learning how Civil War was originally intended to be told and appreciating the complexity of creating a series that affects just about every other title running at that time. Plus, Civil War #1-7 were only a part of the story. The thing that made Civil War work as an event were the tie-ins and getting to see how it played out in all the other Marvel books. Now that Marvel have collected all the tie-in issues and mini-series stuff into six more hardcover editions, it's worth getting the lot to really see how the story plays out in its entirety.
On its own, Civil War as a series is probably somewhere between a 3 or 4 star story. The hardback version's extras are probably worth 4 or 5 stars and give you plenty of extra reading. So, for the hardcover, that balances out as a four.

This is what the marvel universe needed, a story to change everything and add some direction to some lesser known characters. Not to mention culling a few characters. The art throughout is superb, and it is all by the same artist which adds to the consistancy of the story. A couple of major events happen within this book, but the ramifications are dealt with in the individual comic books. This book carries the main story where as the other books fill in the detail. An essential read for all moarvelites.

Now I've been looking at getting into graphic novels for a long time and I have always been very interested in the Marvel Universe and the prospect of a civil war as depicted in this book. Although I've never read a single comic book in my life, I've always been aware of the great superheroes and their particular backgrounds. Apart from the odd one or two however, seriously, who the hell are Goliath and Wasp? This being my first graphic novel and with me generally being a comic book snob and turning my nose up at any comic book or graphic novel, I was genuinely surprised by how much I was taken in by the story and enjoyed the artwork.

The story starts off with young aspiring superheroes doing a bit of crime fighting for a reality TV show, but something goes wrong and one of the villains attacked is a living bomb and explodes killing a lot of civilians and destroying a hell of a lot of land and homes. This is the fuse that sets off the bomb (metaphorically speaking) which is the mass appeal for a Superhero Registration Act. This ensures that all those who are born with or gain super powers are to register to and work for the government as a superhero police force, or risk being locked away for vigilantism or being a danger to the public if they refuse to register.

Reed Richards and Iron Man are in favour of the act and lead their army in finding and capturing the opposition which is led by Captain America, who simply wants to retain his freedom. The side of Iron man argues that working for the government as part of a policing force would place superhero teams distributed across all states, creating a balanced super protection force. It would also allow superheroes to be paid for their services and give them accountability for the damage caused by the means of which they use to stop the super villains and if there are any civilian casualties.

Of course, with two of the Marvel Universe's most politically minded characters, Captain America and Tony Stark disagreeing there were bound to be massive fireworks. The fireworks are not just sparklers that you wave in your friends face and accidentally stab them in the eye with it, landing them in hospital and blind in one eye; these are nuclear bombs of a superhero breed. Featuring some of the biggest superheroes in the Marvel Universe as a part of the front line army, you really get to feel the epic nature of the situation being depicted in the story.

Mark Millar of Wanted movie and comic book fame pens the storyline for this one and from what I knew about the main characters before going into the story, his writing style really manages to emphasise the individuals core personality and allows you to truly understand their motivation. Tony Stark being a government weaponry guy, would naturally be in agreement with this act as it would allow for S.H.I.E.L.D. to gain a more prominent role in U.S. civilian protection, and Captain America feels that it would be unconstitutional to force superheroes to register against their will and fights in favour of an Americans basic freedoms.

The illustrations by Steve McNivern and colouring by Morry Hollowell is really well done and again presents the epic nature of the story and the settings brilliantly. Supremely artistic allows it to become all the more appealing to the reader, as it's not only exciting and enjoyable to read, but really beautiful to look at and enjoy visually. After reading this, I really want to get into graphic novels and see some more work by Mark Millar meaning my next read may be "Red Son" the Superman story set in an alternative universe where he lands in Cold War Russia rather than America. Maybe I'll just join the hysteria and buy Watchmen, but overall I loved this book and for anyone else looking at getting into graphic novels I would say this would be a great starting point.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 26 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

 

5.0 out of 5 stars Above and beyond any other marvel comic I've ever read.
It starts with a catastrophe that rocked the world. It ends with the fight that will change it forever.
Civil war is outstanding from beginning to end. Read more

Published 1 day ago by Patricia

5.0 out of 5 stars An epic story
Civil War is an epic story in both scope and artistic excellence. it is a rollercoaster of a story that I find impossible to put down. Read more

Published 4 months ago by Too old to be collecting Actio...

3.0 out of 5 stars The SENTRY!
SPOILER (kinda...)

Toward the end of the book when Captain America and his merry band break into Rykers Island super prison to try and free the heroes there; The Sentry... Read more

Published 9 months ago by R. A. Shah

2.0 out of 5 stars Terrible ending!
I really, really loved this comic, but the final pages ruined the whole story. It looks like the writer had to make a story in which the one of the sides in the conflict was... Read more

Published 9 months ago by Oeyvind

4.0 out of 5 stars Civil War - A complementary Overview
Maria Hill.
Steve McNiven's Maria Hill to be precise.
I have never encountered such a wonderfully, well rounded female character. Read more

Published 10 months ago by J. P. Marsh

5.0 out of 5 stars Great!
Great sellers, would definitely buy again from them. Thanks again. The comic is in good condition although a slight nick on the top assuming its journey to me but still happy and... Read more

Published 13 months ago by SnakeySR

4.0 out of 5 stars Story and art as good as you'd expect, but production?
Mark Millar has shown with his unmissable Ultimates books that he has a playful and yet thrilling take on the well-loved stable of Marvel characters. Read more

Published 13 months ago by mikey

4.0 out of 5 stars Interesting concept
This review is based on this novel, from 1-7 (I am not sure if there were more out after it). It was a great concept, very different/unique but I found it to be too short. Read more

Published 14 months ago by Mr. R. Safadi

3.0 out of 5 stars Good but not as expected
I firstly read the Road to Civil War and i was very impressed, so i was eager for the Civil War.
The story is nice and has many exciting moments, but overall i expected more... Read more

Published 22 months ago by N. Kanellopoulos

5.0 out of 5 stars Fine piece of art
A very well made compilation of the whole Civil War story. All 7 Comics in 1 Book. Awesome art, great story - what more do you need? It's epic

Published 24 months ago by Christian Baudach

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 26 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

Search Listmania!