First of all let me say how difficult it is to review a Christmas CD.
There are so many out there, satisfying the "We need a carol cd for the party" purchaser, "What's cheap?" or "Anything as long as I know them all!" buyer.
This recording does not fall into any of the above categories thank goodness, although perhaps in terms of sales figures it may help!
Yes there are some of the well known traditional carols there, utilising some slightly different arrangements and descants, all which work admirably, but it's where the less run of the mill pieces come in that this recording really scores.James Burton's setting of Balulalow is beautifully sung, and emphasises the intimacy of the St John's chapel with sublime and subtle harmony.
Mathias's A Babe Is Born is full of the open intervals that are his trademark,and is executed with panache by the choir.Richard Rodney Bennett's "Out of your Sleep" reaches back to the late 60's. His output then was different to his current jazz dominated career,writing choral pieces and small scale opera. The tight jazz tinged harmony sits well with the 15th century text and challenges the choir enough to ensure some delicious rhythmical singing, the tenors excelling.
Christopher Robinson's "Make we Joy" shows the choir at its best tackling the lively rhythm and crisp attack needed for a vibrant and briefly stunning performance. The choir delivers in true Robinson style, I am sure the former Choir Director will be delighted with this performance.
At this point the CD reaches its peak. What is it about St Johns and Tavener? Is there a choir anywhere that performs his works with such passion, presence and beauty? The Naxos recording by St Johns under Christopher Robinson was a thing of rare beauty, but this version of The Lamb soars into the heavens with such clarity and perfect singing, it is hard to find the superlatives to do it justice.The performance makes the CD worth the cover price alone.
Before the recording ends with some more familiar settings, the Finnissy "Telling" grabbed me straight away. The choir, unaccompanied showing perfect harmonic awareness and continuity to demonstrate how moving and colourful choral music can be. A joy to listen to.
One slight gripe, is the use of one or two slightly dated sounding arrangements. A personal thing perhaps but Willcocks' "Tomorrow Shall Be My Dancing Day " just sounds dated, and has not worn well. Given some of the fresher interpretations on the recording it seems a shame that some more new ones weren't unearthed.Oddly it is here that the choir does sound a little lacklustre.
The sleeve notes are superb, and the packaging, in particular the photos, goes a long way to show that the Choir is a thoroughly modern set up, although firmly rooted in the past, it is constantly looking forward .
All in all a fabulous CD, under Andrew Nethsinga, the choir continues to march forward, leaving the "Noisy Neighbours" down the road in their wake!