It's not easy trying to figure out how many stars to give this book. Although I found most of it to be well written with information potentially very useful to a parent with an autistic child, the author makes blanket statements in favor of unproven and disproven treatment methods that ultimately might offset the usefulness of everything else.
My immediate advice to any readers is to take everything in this book as just suggestions on things that might be beneficial to your child, and don't count on anything to work for sure until you've given it a try and found positive results for yourself.
Both of our children, an 8-year-old daughter and a 12-year-old son, are autistic, and we as a family have struggled through many extremely difficult years desperately trying to find ways to deal with the problems their condition causes in their schools, among our extended families, and in society in general. My son has always used tactile forms of communication when he gets excited, which means he often casually touches people when he likes them and pushes (or hits) others when he gets upset, all of which are very frowned upon in our culture. My daughter goes off into her own world without seeming to understand what's being told to her, then she suddenly she breaks out into hysterics at what seem to others to be trivial offenses, or she bursts into loud singing and wild giggling fits to the disruption of those around her. Both children have been measured to have very high intelligence (enough to put them into gifted classrooms), but their autistic mindsets cause them to fall behind other children their age in some of the simplest activities (such as potty training, which led my daughter to being the only child in her kindergarten who still needed to wear a diaper to class).
Our children's issues manifested at an early age, so we dove into doing research and attempting solutions, using every avenue possible. We slowly found some good information and techniques, but we also encountered a lot of ideas and theories (often from well-meaning individuals) that proved worse than useless, not only wasting large amounts of our time but even potentially causing damage to our child's development (such as by allowing our children to be in the care of teachers who directed overly harsh approaches to problems).
As I read "My Child Has Autism, Now What?" I thought about our struggles and wished we had had a book like this presented to us when our children were toddlers. Many of the methods the author presents were ones we found extremely useful in helping our own children, such as developing very distinct routines in the day, using sensory-integration techniques as a way for our children to focus their energies, simplifying areas of the home (in particular, severely limiting distractions such as the television and video games), and using music to create a calming atmosphere (particularly at night after the children were tucked into bed). I wish we had known years ago what we know now about how school systems are legally required (when formally requested) to test children at a very early age to determine if they require special assistance (and to provide the assistance at no charge if needed). Without a doubt, the author's list of resources on finding information on that and other issues is wonderful. Several chapters of this book presented some great ideas on taking what we've already done even further, and I'm looking forward to applying some of her techniques in attempt to make our lives calmer and more under control.
That being said, the book has some serious problems. In particular, I was appalled when Kidd presented an entire chapter on "biomedical intervention." She started the chapter saying there has been an increase in research attempting to "cure" autism, as if it's a disease like cancer or tuberculosis. Autism, simply put, is not a disease, any more than being left handed or having gender-identity disorder. It's a way a person's brain is wired from before birth, and it's not something that can be changed with drugs, herbs, vitamins, avoiding milk or eating different types of breakfast cereal (all of which some so-called "experts" have recommended as potential "cures" for autism in children). Unfortunately, in chapter eight of the book, Kidd reveals she falls into the camp of the many parents who blame technology and culture (by attacking artificial colors and preservatives) while desperately clinging to the hope that a magical treatment exists that can undo the way their child was formed by nature. Yes, it's possible that some chemicals in our culture affect the behavior of an autistic child in ways that they don't affect a child without autism, but such ideas haven't been proven yet in independent case studies, and where they do seem to work they definitely don't benefit every child to an equal amount. However, Kidd seems to feel that putting your child on a lactose-free, gluten-free, organic diet is the way to go for fighting the issues caused by an autistic brain. She flat out lists the "steps to health" for an autistic child are adding supplements, regulating their diet, "detoxifying" their system (by using "earth-friendly" soaps and toothpastes), and even modifying or delaying their scheduled vaccinations (which she said could "disturb their development"). The book would be greatly improved if the chapter on "biomedical intervention" was entirely removed from the rest of the text, or at most moved to a minor appendix listing unproven theories.
Finally, I had a hard time taking the book seriously at times because of the writer's style. The layout was occasionally confusing and unprofessional, and her choice of fonts made it seem like the book was intended more for children than their parents. It was apparent Kidd was trying to present a friendly tone and make her work easily readable, but sometimes I felt she was dumbing things down and even being patronizing. For example, one chapter has the following instruction for parents: "... notice any change in behavior, language, sleeping, and eliminating (yes, pooping!)." I would think than any adult reading this could figure out "eliminating" has to do with bodily wastes, but couldn't the author had used something like "bowel movements" instead of reaching to the level of "pooping"?
Overall, this book had several chapters that I would rate individually with four or five stars. Unfortunately, the author's style of writing and the presentation of the book at most rate three or four stars. Worst of all, though, the author presents unproven and potentially damaging theories as if they're tried-and-true medical pathways to success, and that sheds a poor light, casting doubt on everything else in the volume.
So the most I can give this book is an iffy three stars. I would definitely recommend that the parents of a young child with autism read Kidd's work, but with a warning to take what the author says with a grain of salt at times - and to have a huge block of it nearby during a couple of the later chapters.
__ Reviewed by Brianna __