Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
very, very good ; but not inspired, 28 April 2007
I enjoyed this set, with the substantial extra material, a lot of which is very interesting, particularly the extended version of particular numbers, in which you get some ides of how they were prepared and rehearsed. It's an excellent show anyway, with a lovely, quick paced seedy atmosphere, and it is very, very professionally done. Why not 5 stars? Well, I enjoy the work of Renee Zelwegger, Catherine Zeta Jones and Richard Gere - they are all very skilled, very professional and very, very good, and their performances give a lot of pleasure, but I never feel that any one of them is a died-in-the-wool vaudeville performer, a true music hall artiste. At its worst (and this impression is only very occasional) it just seems a little too much like hard work. It is a very carping criticism, but whereas, say, Liza Minelli in 'Cabaret' seemed born to the role, these three are more like fine professionals who won it at audition and have done a fine, conscientious job. But no-one should hesitate from buying the set. It does pretty good justice to a very good show and is very good value for money.
|
|
|
78 of 93 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Shoot the Disc Compiler, 4 Sep 2006
I saw this version of 'Chicago' on television about a year ago and thought it was sensational, as a film I would give it a hundred stars if I could. My 'one star' rating is a reflection of how enraged I was at the way this DVD has been produced. The box says "Dual Layer Format. Layer transition may trigger a slight pause." Well, nice of them to warn us but what an understatement that turned out to be. The first 50 minutes or so were fine but after that the picture continually 'froze' for a few seconds before resuming. This was disruptive enough during 'conversational' scenes but when musical numbers (including my favourite song, 'Razle Dazzle' which I had been waiting for) were interrupted like this I found it impossible to watch. I know nothing about 'layer transition' and the rest of the technicalities but I think it is unforgivable to put such a flawed product on the market and to ruin a wonderful film such as this in this dreadful way. I urge you not to buy this edition. Don't even think about it.
|
|
|
9 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Layer Transition, 5 Jan 2007
Layer transition should only happen once during the movie, usually about halfway through, this effectively allows the dvd to hold twice as much data. The laser refocuses to pass through the first layer to focus on the second, this should last much less than a second and should appear as at worst a slight blip. Nearly every DVD released now uses this technology, much better than the old days of DVD-5 discs which you had to flip halfway through the movie (such a pain in the a@@). If you are having this much problem with the movie you most likely have a mispressed faulty disc, this would not be indicative of the entire batch release or they would have a major problem.
As for the movie great fun, well choreographed and well acted. A great screen production of the musical.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|