With female public figures such as Kim Cattrall, Tilda Swinton and Madonna being celebrated rather than denigrated for taking in toyboy lovers and given the huge popularity of costume dramas in recent decades, it's not difficult to imagine why an adaptation of Colette's 1920 and 1926 novellas was an attractive prospect for director Stephen Frears and writer Christopher Hampton. The Chéri novellas by Colette (1873-1954) detail the romantic entanglement of the 49 year-old Léa de Lonval (Michelle Pfeifer) with Fred 'Chéri' Peloux (Rupert Friend), who is 24 years her junior.
But Frears' version of Chéri is underwhelming. The camera seems more obsessed with the faces of Pfeifer and Friend than preoccupied with character or narrative development. The script is unconvincing at key moments: you don't believe that the decadent and petulent Chéri would actually buckle to maternal pressure to produce grandchildren at all. Nor that he would so suddenly be prepared to marry the anodyne Edmee (Felicity Jones) after a passionate, semi-Oedipal affair with the far more experienced Léa. Rupert Friend (The Young Victoria, Pride and Prejudice) is good on the arrogant petulence but acts here with the same kind of restrained feeling as his girlfriend Keira Knightley, which prevents serious emotional and sympathetic involvement of the audience with the characters they are endeavouring to embody. Felicity Jones (Northanger Abbey, Brideshead Revisited) has a tendency to act self-consciously (I felt conscious that she is acting rather than *being* the character) and it feels as though Pfeifer is going through the motions a bit here, perhaps a little bored or underchallenged in this environment. The Kathy Bates figure (she plays Chéri's mother) is more of a caricature than a character, as is true of some of the side characters, which is partly a fault of the script.
Costume dramas have become progressively less challenging and more homogenous and commercial since their heyday in the 1980s and mid-1990s when the 11-episode epic of Brideshead Revisited hit the TV screens (1981), the Pride & Prejudice miniseries starring Colin Firth and Jennifer Ehle aired (1995) and Carrington - directed by Chéri writer Christopher Hampton - debuted (1995). Nowadays dramas of the same genre try more often than not to seduce you more simply: through visual charms, an easily digestible romantic narrative, and diverse anachronisms (e.g. muscular bodies that can only be so sculpted by time spent lifting machine weights in a fitness studio). Keen to repay the multi-million pound investment that studios have put into such pictures and to find commercial success, directors know that audiences are receptive to accessibility and digestibility of this kind, but they will always leave some people in the audience, who might be hoping for a return to the golden days of period drama, wanting something more.