Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
3.0 out of 5 stars
Divided views, 4 Jan 2009
'Chasing the Deer' is a tale set during the Jacobite Rising of 1745/46 based around a Highland 'tacksman' and his son who are both reluctantly dragged into service on opposing sides, culminating in a tragic meeting at the disastrous Battle of Culloden.
The portrayals of the various well-known characters such as Charles Stuart, Lord George Murray and William O'Sullivan are the commonly accepted views of their personas i.e Charles;an ignorant,arrogant, stubborn buffoon, Murray; a hotheaded but wise and battle-hardened commander and O'Sullivan as an excitable idiot.The portrayal of all i feel is fairly accurate,drawing conclusion from pieces I have read on the subject.
It is refreshing to see a decent attempt at telling the harsh realities of the '45 and how families could become embroiled in war on opposing sides, willingly or not.Such an instance of course occured with the sons of the chief of Clan Chisholm during the rising as well as several others.
Budget constraints somewhat limit the effectiveness of the large-scale battle scenes at Prestonpans and Culloden as it often looks like twenty men against twenty rather than several thousand on each side.The fighting scenes are fairly realistic however despite a few invisible (but fatal) blows.
Some of the acting leaves a wee bit to be desired,such as the son, Ewen Campbell but most play their parts competently, including a brooding cameo by the singer 'Fish',who incidentally is one who falls victim to one of the unseen but decisive blows.
Leys Castle Moor and the countryside around Inverness provides the backdrop for the battlefield scenes which to be fair is not unlike Culloden considering it is barely five miles from where they were filmed.
To sum up, a good, realistic effort at telling the story and the film is undeniably entertaining although it is slightly on the short side.I live in hope that a big-budget film will be made on the '45, with more historical accuracy than films such as 'Braveheart' but losing none of the passion.
|
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
It has it faults but has a good heart., 23 Oct 2008
I have read a few reviews for Chasing The Deer,ok its not Braveheart or Rob Roy,this was due to budget,but it does have a heart,there is some historical discrepencies but dosent distract from the fact that Scotland was totally divided over the return of Bonnie Prince Charlie.
I was an extra on this film,getting killed as a Redcoat at Prestonpans,Highlander at Culloden,Ambushed and also hung in the town square (deleted scene),i enjoyed the experience and am proud of the film.
|
|
|
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Good attempt, 21 Feb 2008
This is one of the very few films about the Jacobite rebellion of 1745 and so is to be welcomed for that. The film has many virtues, but could have been better.
Firstly there is no romanticism as most of the ordinary Scots shown here are either apathetic to the Jacobite cause or hostile to it, save for a single enthusiast. We also see alllegedly pro-government Scots wondering if they should show some support to the Jacobites as they might win.
The Jacobite forces prior to Culloden are noted as lacking suppleis, which is accurate.
The battle scene at Culloden is well done, but there were no cavalrymen, presumably due to budgetary considerations. Even so, this is a loss, for the regular cavalry played a key role in the battle.
Although Ruthven barracks are the setting for a number of scenes, the 2 sieges of the barracks are neither shown nor referred to.
However, the Jacobite army is shown as a purely Highland host, armed with swords and lochaber axes, whereas in reality there were many Lowlanders and more men had muskets as well as, or instead of, swords.
Cumberland and his forces are shown marching out of Fort George - which was not built until 20 years later and is in Scotland - they are meant to be in England. We also hear that prior to this Cumberland et al are in France, whereas they were not.
Charles Edward Stuart is happily not shown in kilt, but he remains remarkably calm during the stormy conference in Derby.
Finally the alleged emotional impact is lost because we can guess the ending and in any case, we don't see enough of the characters to bewail their fates overmuch.
Despite these criticisms, the film avoids many of the possible anachronisms and blunders that it could easily have included. Having Stuart Reid as the historical adviser certainly helped.
|
|
|
|
![Culloden 1746 - The Last Highland Charge [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51X85F8K2GL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ David Chandler; Brian Blessed
![The Bruce [VHS] [1996]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41SFBQND72L._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
VHS ~ Brian Blessed
With an Amazon.co.uk Gift Certificate, you can get them what they want (even if you don't know what that is). 
Amazon Home