The author quite clearly has a tremendous admiration for Charlie Tully, one of Celtic's greatest ever players. But this is more than merely a biography. Charlie Tully is put in his context of being born and brought up in poverty-ridden Belfast in 1924, of the collapse of Belfast Celtic in 1949, of Charlie's move to Glasgow in 1948 and of his tragically early death in 1971. The author rightly condemns the shambles that was Celtic in the 1950s and points the finger at the guilty men who saw Celtic with better and more talented players than Rangers, nevertheless come second best - and not even that some times! Incompetence (breathtaking sometimes) at the top is dealt with, as are hints of corruption on the playing field. This book is not an encomium of Tully - his faults, like his reluctance to train as hard as he should and his fondness for alcohol in later life, are detailed, but the talent of Charlie Tully shines through. It is an honest appraisal of a basically lovely, brilliant but occasionally irresponsible player. This book, well written and well researched, is worth its price, and will be an asset to the bookshlef of any football lover.
David Potter