A REVIEW OF `CHALLENGE' BY SAPPER
`Challenge' was the last of the ten original Bulldog Drummond novels penned by the hero's creator H.C. McNeile (aka Sapper) who sadly died in 1937. First published in that same year, `Challenge' dives feet-first into a story brimming with action, espionage and escapism. The plot revolves around Drummond's attempts to thwart a gang of international terrorists plotting to destroy Britain and the British Empire from within using cells of Communists / anarchists to carry out their dirty work. The leaders of said gang are apparently respectable members of society, which makes the job a tad tricky for Hugh and his buddies.
Those familiar with the Bulldog Drummond books will recognise the footprints of a tried-and-tested formula in my plot summary. Indeed, many of the series essential elements are here*. For example, master-villain Charles Burton has a veneer of respectability similar to that of Carl Peterson in the first four novels. Likewise, we have the usual blend of fist-fights and banter throughout the yarn.
However, having hit double Drummond figures, Sapper does offer some freshness. The first half of the story is very much a game of cat-and-mouse with Drummond and Ronald Standish being chased across France and The Low Countries by their shadowy enemies. With its French Riviera setting, parts of `Challenge' could even be described as glamorous, foreshadowing the exotic locales of the forthcoming Bond novels, now only 15-or-so years away. It is in its first half and final quarter that `Challenge' really succeeds. The chasing and duelling of goodies and baddies is very well-handled, offering an increased sense of pace akin to that found in John Buchan's best work.
Sadly, the momentum is lost somewhat by a third quarter which reads more like a P.G. Wodehouse Blandings Castle novella that a genuine thriller. As entertaining as it may be, the section devoted to Algy Longworth's buffoonery in Burton's stately home, rather interrupts the urgency and excitement. All of which is a great shame, as the truly explosive Cornish-set finale is arguably the best of the series. Returning briefly to a certain Mr Fleming, did I spot a huge similarity with `Dr No' in the villain's attempts to conceal their evil-doings from the local populace?
Thus, despite its uneven structure, `Challenge' is a worthy goodbye from Sapper to Hugh Drummond after 17 years of blood-and-thunder antics. Drummond would soon return, not only in 5 posthumously-published Sapper short stories, but also via seven new novels penned by Sapper's official successor, Gerard Fairlie. I shall enjoy rejoining him in them. However, as boys'-own-adventures very taken in their correct context (and with tongue lodged securely in cheek) the original tales will take some beating.
Barty's Score: 8.5 / 10
* Bizarrely, one element missing from `Challenge' is Drummond's wife, Phyllis. In previous adventures her increasingly low-profile would be politely explained by her being overseas or shopping. Here, she does not even get a mention!