I don't understand the previous reviews at all. I've read the author's earlier books and this is not simply "more of the same".
This book is fascinating and very well written. Its so rare to come across a book that gets into the nuts and bolts of what looking after a cat is about, from someone that actually studies cats in their homes.
The book talks about single and multi-cat households, multi-species households and inter-species relationships, nervous, aggressive and dependent cats, before ending with an interesting theory on why women love cats, and then the survey. And as a man, I can assure Mrs Halls that I love my cats very much!
One thing that became more obvious the longer you read the book was that it wasn't the cats with the problems, but the owners. For example, one woman who lived in a designer flat with her two designer cats had basically starved them to death to the extent they were chewing the furniture and anything else they could get their teeth into. And she wondered what the problem was! When the svelte shape of her cats was pointed out to her, her comment was: "I really do believe you can never be too rich or too thin and that goes for my cats too!" Should people like that be allowed to own cats?
There are countless other examples of owner's...well let's be kind and call it naivety, and I think the best line in the book is reserved for those owners that never let their cats outside. Whilst this is often done for the best of reasons, it in fact often causes behavioural problems. I can't find the exact quote, but it talks about the importance of putting to one side your own concerns and what you feel is best, at the expense of the needs and requirements of your cat. Yes, life is dangerous outside and anything might happen, but surely its better for a cat to physically experience a life than be forced to watch one through a window.
In conclusion, this is a marvellous book and I hope you enjoy reading it as much as I did.