|
|
32 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A well-edited selection, but why not the Complete Stories?, 10 Nov 2000
By A Customer
'Casting the Runes' collects eighteen of the stories whose publication made the reputation of their author as one of the finest of the English supernaturalists. It adds three late stories, 'An Experiment' (1931), 'The Malice of Inanimate Objects' (1933), and 'A Vignette' (1936), which appeared in magazines after the publication of the otherwise definitive 'Collected Ghost Stories' of 1931, and which some readers will judge not to be among the author's best. The editor of this selection is the author's biographer, and he has revisited the original manuscripts to produce revised versions in the case of about half the stories in the collection. The stories are annotated and difficult terms glossed, and some non-fiction material has been included, in particular the well known piece 'Stories I Have Tried to Write'. The stories included are of course peerless examples of their kind, and in other circumstances I would be able to recommend this volume without hesitation, but most readers will want to read all of James, and thirty stories are available (as they appeared in the 1931 collection) in other, cheaper editions. Notably, at the time of writing of this review, the Wordsworth edition reprints (for a pound!) the 1931 volume in its entirety, excluding the three uncollected pieces but including the essay mentioned above. This leaves this Oxford volume to recommend itself on the basis of the editor's valuable contributions and the three uncollected stories, which the reader looking for the best value in James editions may find an inadequate inducement. What a shame that Oxford were not able to produce an annotated Complete Stories to supersede the 1931 reprint.
|