Linda Grant's ambitious and panoramic novel could perhaps be described as a paradox: the 'great American novel' written by an English journalist, about a third of which takes place in Liverpool. But this is to be perhaps too flippant about a book which I found convincing and compulsive. It provoked for me favourable comparisons with another work tackling similar themes of exile, political commitment and sacrifice - Philip Roth's American Pastoral. Grant of course is lacking the years of experience of Roth, and my only criticism would be that some of the plotting is a little loose and one or two of the recurring metaphors a little leaden, but these are minor complaints in a novel so sympathetically relayed. Grant also, of course, manages something which Roth could never be accredited with: a coherent and sympathetic feminine perspective.