The mixed range of responses from the other reviews showing here suggest that a further opinion may help to put this music into a wider perspective.
It's surely an error of fairly high order to dismiss Carter's output as "just not musical". The song cycles, the soaring trumpet solo that opens the Symphony of Three Orchestras, the passionate viola cadenza in the 2nd quartet, the central wind chorale in the Double Concerto, the cloud-like clusters of pianissimo strings the conclude the piano concerto, the seemingly effortless elegance of Dialogues (the late "second" piano concerto), the lento espressivo of the 5th quartet - these are just a few examples of truly poetic musicality in Carter. So let's not worry on that point. Indeed I would add the awesome devastation of the slow movement of the big Symphony here as a further example of Carter at his most deeply human.
I also doubt that it's helpful to make glib comparisons between one and another composer as though they were being numbered above or below one another in this week's hit parade. It's not unfair to comment that the Symphony here has leanings to the portentous, and I have some sympathy with another comment here that the music is exposed to criticism for being "in ragged state", although to my ears Carter's music is far less open to criticism on this count than some others mentioned.
I give this disc five stars because
- I think the performances are mightily impressive
- I think the quality of the recorded sound is fine
- I think the music is full of attractive writing and often marvellous invention; and
- I love Carter's originality of language.
Actually the clarinet concerto falls on my ears as a slightly angular piece - generally I am more an admirer of Carter's purer thought-forms than of his concertante writing. If you want to get to know Carter's sound world, then you should certainly start with earlier music of his than that presented here. But once you are caught up in his manner, you'll surely come to appreciate this excellent disc. I particularly admire the absence of the finale to the Symphony - it has a direct link back to Bruckner's 9th as a musical ancestor in this respect, aside from the direct relationship in the grandeur of the respective slow movements.
Best wishes on your aural travels ... this disc is well worth the effort.