Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Superb satire - hilarious, 8 Jan 2010
This review is from: Can I Recycle My Granny?: And 39 Other Eco-dilemmas (Paperback)
The purpose, of course, is to show the absurdity of environmentalist thinking, something which at least two reviewers here have failed to grasp. The basic point is a serious one: that green ideology is deeply and scarily misanthropic. This is imaginatively worked throughout and hilariously taken to extremis. This is satire at its best, readable, funny, entertaining and never losing sight of an important message. Ed Miliband should be sent a copy - urgently, as his thinking unfortunately seems to be veering dangerously towards Greenhart's. Fantastic book!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Only the totally po-faced and humorless won't appreciate this gem, 23 Dec 2010
This review is from: Can I Recycle My Granny?: And 39 Other Eco-dilemmas (Paperback)
. Don't listen to the achingly serious, po-faced miseries who've posted their disapproval of a book that dares to poke a little light fun at environmentalism. This is a witty look at how a serious issue - environmental protection - somehow gets twisted around into a form of elitism, where the working and lower-middle classes get blamed for just being normal, whilst the professional and upper-middle classes (who as we all know pollute the most) largely exculpate themselves from any blame, as they "carbon-offset" and buy organic, etc, etc. This is NOT an anti-green book, as some reviewers have suggested. To think this shows a lack of finesse and subtlety and a failure to appreciate the shades of difference between parody, lampoon and satire. It is a witty, but gentle, reproof to environmentalists that understanding and tolerance are essential aspects of being green. Anyone who cares about both the environment and people (and who is capable of smiling and laughing) will appreciate this little satirical gem. Open your mind, and give it a try.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
This book is a spoof written by an anti-green, 29 Aug 2009
This review is from: Can I Recycle My Granny?: And 39 Other Eco-dilemmas (Paperback)
Just for anyone that is not aware, this book is actually a spoof lampooning the green movement written by arch-anti-green, Brendan O'Neill. Although some aspects of green-ism can be comical and extreme, O'Neill in his writings elsewhere seems to dismiss all green issues completely. He continually rails against a so-called "liberal elite", although he is not exactly clear who these people are, and he continually talks about "the masses" or "the working class", implying that a lot of current arguments and opinions are against them. Thus, O'Neill seems to view any attack or critique of things from cheap flights to violence at football matches as an a attack on the working class, without seeming to realise that things such as global warming and violence affect poorer people more severely than the better off. O'Neill tends to stereotype poorer people as all sharing a number of negative characteristics, and then implies that any critique of such negative things is an attack on poorer people, or the masses. He doesn't appear to make any allowances for the fact that the less powerful in society might actually be quite diverse, and do not necessarily fall into a stereotype, eg: the tattooed football hooligan. O'Neill's arguments tend to be very ad hominem, for example, he critices the perceived social standing of those who hold certain views on issues such as green issues, hooliganism, supermarkets, rather than addressing the issues and arguments themselves. Enjoy this book by all means, but don't take it too seriously. Weigh up the arguments for yourself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|