I ordered the guide so that I could use if for a recent Holiday in Normandy and Brittany. First of all the guide is in French with an English introduction, but that’s
Fine as even I can read enough French to understand it. The information given for each site is good in so much as it lists every thing the site has, however quality doesn’t seem to have been assessed and the star rating system (in the guides case how many mountains it has?) is wildly inaccurate.
One site we stayed on which had a good rating only had one toilet block, which was on the other side of a main road! Another site we stayed on had a low rating but was (although small) excellent. Another site had loads of pitches but most weren’t level and the one we did pick (in the dark) was so saturated that our camper van sunk into it and had to be towed out with a four-wheel drive!
Another problem with the guide is that it’s difficult to look up sites. There is a map at the start of each section with all the sites marked on it. In the text each area is subdivided into departments and the sites are arranged in alphabetical order. In order to find a site you have to look at the map work out which department its in and then thumb through to find that department in the text and then thumb through some more to find the site within the department. Occasionally there are smaller maps but the sites marked on theses often aren’t on the same page as the map.
In the end we used the guide only to work out which sites were still open (we went camping in October) and when we got to a site we tried to inspect it first before staying. This isn’t something you should have to do with a good guide.
To sum up the Michelin guide has the makings of a good guide but it desperately needs its site inspections reviewing and its layout up dating.
P.S. This assessment is only based on about 6 sites visited so it may be I was just unlucky.