I admit that I was mildly disappointed when I first started this game. The graphics are fantastic (as good as Far Cry 2 or the latest Call of Duty games) but the first chapter, based on the American Civil war has an oddly retro feel about the gameplay. It feels like you are back in Call of Duty 2 with different weapons and uniforms.
However, once you are transported into the (brilliantly rendered) Wild West, the fun really begins! You really become a Clint Eastwood anti-hero.
In most FPS games, I barely use side arms. They are usually pathetic, almost useless pieces of kit. However, in this game, the pistol is king. There are several from which to choose. All of them deadly. They vary between the very powerful but slow loading, to the less powerful but quicker loading. They are so good, I forgot I had a rifle at times.
There are plenty of weapons available from dead victims. However, better, shinier ones are available for a price from the gun stores, so you need to pick up cash whenever you find it.
There are a few innovations. There is "concentration" mode which slows down the action to take on multiple targets. I didn't use it much. There is also "cover" mode, which crouches your character behind cover if you approach a corner or crate etc. The mouse then creates a rolling sort of movement which allows you to expose a minimum amount of yourself to enemy fire. It works well but may not be everybody's cup of tea.
You also have gunfights. This is done with the keyboard moving your character left and right to keep your (moving) opponent focussed in the centre of the screen. At the same time, you have to keep your gun hand close to the pistol. Irritatingly, it tends to drift away. You then draw when a bell rings and hope you hit your target before you take a bullet between the eyes. It takes quite a bit of practice to win a fight and become a "fast gun".
There are some excellent cut scenes. However, unlike the dreadful epics in Brothers in Arms, you can skip them.
With the exception of a few side missions you can take on at the gun stores, the game is very linear. It doesn't matter. There is plenty of action and alternate routes from which to choose. You can play as two different characters and it's very replayable, anyway. As a bonus, you don't need to load a disk. You can just click the icon and off you go!
In conclusion:
BAD (ish):
Poor start
MATTER OF TASTE:
Linear (could have been like Far Cry 2)
Concentration Mode
Cover mode
Gun Fights
GOOD:
Excellent Graphics
Horse riding
Absorbing story
Superb weapons, especially pistols
Good cut scenes (you can skip them)
FUN FUN FUN!
I loved it! When is the sequel coming out.....?