5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A dangerous publication, 27 April 2005
This review is from: CHAPATIS FOR TEA: Loving Your Hindu Neighbour (Paperback)
This is a very disturbing publication whose sole aim is to undermine hindu beliefs in order to bring about conversion to christianity. Mr.Gidoomal is happy to portray himself as a 'friend' of the UK Asian and Hindu community but this is a none-too-subtle mask of his real intentions: Christian Missionary Activity. Indeed for all his airs and graces, Mr Gidoomal is no better that the 19th Century Indologists who decided to study the Vedic literatures in order to convert the heathen hindu to the 'light' of christianity.
On page 13 of this work, it is written that: "We must not relinquish our conviction that the Christian faith shows us the only true way to God and that other religions cannot save people" - so according to the authors no Hindu (no matter how kind and generous he is) can achieve heavenly reward - this is plain religious chauvinism that one may expect from a fundamentalist in the US Bible-Belt or a zealous islamic preacher NOT an alleged 'goodwill ambassador' to the asian community as Mr.Gidoomal.
Other interesting remarks include: (page 126) "Avatars, reincarnations of one of the gods, usually Vishnu, have never atoned for our sins. They are not God in the flesh. They are simply aspects of the Hindu gods, never the total incarnation of every aspect of divinity. Only in Christ is the fullness of God revealed. No Hindu scripture can dispute this".
(page 79): "The Bible is rooted in actual events but much of the Hindu scriptures are unashamedly mythological. There is no historical evidence for many of the events described"
(page 139): "Hindus do not distinguish clearly between history and legends....A Hindu sees little difference between the stories of Krishna and Rama (which seem legendary to us) and those about Jesus. However the stories of the former grew from literary origins whereas those of Jesus are based on accounts of actual eye witnesses"
This is nothing but a crude missionary pamphlet and it should be avoided by all persons with humility and kindness. Hindus have great respect for Lord Jesus Christ but this does NOT mean that we are happy to see our religion denigrated and ourselves patronised by the zealous Mr Gidoomal.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No