This is a funny one. Not literally of course, it's actually rather gloomy, but in terms of the mixed feelings I have always had about it.
`Exile' was the next album after Numan's spectacular return to form on the remarkable `Sacrifice' but for me did not really continue the upward trend. It's in no way a bad album and is very `Numan' throughout, it's just that there is a same-iness to much of the material and to this day I can't tell most of the tracks apart.
Let's put it like this; if like me, you found `Absolution' a bit dull, then it's unlikely that you'll take to `Exile', as most of the songs sound a bit like that, with perhaps slight variations in tempo. The songs worked well live though, where they were interspersed with older, familiar songs, but listened to as an unbroken stream, the album has always seemed a bit one-dimensional to me.
The general atmosphere is very moody, with sparse instrumentation and distant drum-loops, and many of the tracks never really get going. Only `Dominion Day, `Prophecy' and the monumental `Dark' (one of Numan's finest songs and a long-time personal fave) stand out from the inseparable `Angel Wars', `An Alien Cure', `Exile', `Innocence Bleeding', 'Dead Heaven' et al.
The lyrical content sees Numan railing against God, which neither interests nor repels me personally, but it does wear a bit thin by the end of the album.
As ever though, since Gary Numan can't honestly be compared with anyone else, it's all relative, and the music here is still light years ahead of even his best mid-to-late 80's output, so in that respect I do hold it in high regard.
I guess it's a fan thing really; if you are one, you'll already have at least one copy of `Exile' and will have formed your opinion of it years ago. If you're new to Numan though, I think you'll be much more impressed by `Sacrifice' and `Pure' or any of the pre-1985 releases, which you should check out before filling in the gaps with the less essential albums like this.
Like I said, a funny one this.