The first two volumes of The Watcher's Guide contained episode guides that weren't very large or complete, but the books more than made up for it with their detailed behind-the-scenes segments. Being the "official" guides, they had exclusive access to the cast and crew, with exclusive interviews and descriptions of how episodes are made. Volume 3 has been a long time coming, and is almost totally a disappointment. The writers of the first two volumes are gone, and Paul Ruditis has sole credit for this one. The book is totally lacking in behind-the-scenes information, as though Ruditis was denied the exclusive access that this "Official companion" is supposed to have.
The Episode Guide section (which covers seasons 5 to 7) covers each episode with the same detail as previous volumes, which is enough for a casual reader but not really informative. It lacks the behind-the-scenes trivia boxes that were peppered around the previous guides, and it criminally fails to include the listing of music tracks. In place of the huge behind-the-scenes sections from previous Volumes, we now get some amateurish essays instead. A big chunk of the book is padded out with the shooting script for "Restless", a season 4 episode that shouldn't even be covered by this guide. This book is padded out with unnecessary pages, or even blank pages, yet it still doesn't reach the same page count as Volume 2.
As a glossy casual book to be occasionally dipped into, the Watcher's Guide Volume 3 suffices. Its summaries of the episodes in seasons 5 to 7 will jog the memories of casual fans, and it has a lot of pictures. But for serious Buffy fans who expected exclusive and official insight into the show, this is a wasted opportunity and a disappointment.