I bought this book when I was working at a school in the White Highlands of Kenya, as I wanted to learn more about the Mau Mau uprising during the 1950s. Though the book was on the heavy side (and sometimes quite challenging to read) it highlighted many things that have been forgotten in history. I understand that many of the reviews here criticise the book in its apparent agenda, yet Elkins's has done this in order to uncover something that has been denied by the British for a very long time.
We are given a vast amount of witness testimony from the people who suffered, and this sometimes makes you wonder how such an injustice has been covered up. Herein lies the 'problem' with this book. Obviously, Elkins can claim that hard evidence from British records has all been destroyed and that many people affected by the camps are now long gone. But in a country where the life expectancy is under 60 it has been very hard to get accounts from survivors of this time, so first-hand evidence is a little sketchy. However, this could explain why the events appear to have been forgotten in Kenya. Talking to many Kenyans during my time there, there seemed to be little animosity towards to still-present white population (unlike Zimbabwe and South Africa), which is peculiar considering the alleged atrocities. There is close to no evidence from the white Kenyans involved who are still alive now, which fails to ensure a balanced perspective. The eyewitness accounts from those who suffered are endless, but this book does appear over-reliant on these sources.
Though it can be subjective (the atrocities of the Mau Mau rebels isn't dwelled upon), I do feel that one of Britain's past atrocities has been uncovered somewhat, albeit not fully. However, the fact that some camp survivors have now won compensation from the British government makes you wonder whether we have started to accept our nation's role in the uprising.