Most Helpful Customer Reviews
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
What if.........., 15 Mar 2006
By A Customer
This review is from: If Britain Had Fallen (Paperback)
'If Britain had fallen' is a study in alternate history; namely, what would have happened had the war taken a different turn and the Nazis invaded the UK. The book is divided into two parts. The first deals with a fictional scenario concerning the invasion - how the Battle of Britain was lost, the Royal Navy was unable to deny use of the Channel to the Germans, and the subsequent land invasion. If you watched and enjoyed the recent TV show 'The Real Dad's Army' you will find this extremely interesting as the content is very similar. The second part is a study of what the German occupation would have been like. This is essentially an extrapolation from real history, based on knowledge of what happened both on the Channel Islands and Mainland Europe. Its is slightly dry in places but very informative. In general, I thought this was an excellent book; it covers the subject in depth without getting bogged down in tiny details. Some parts of the 'story' Longmate invents, such as Churchill's last stand, are really quite emotive. It is only recently that the real "What if..." story can be fully told as some of the material relating to the county's defence remained classified for a long time. Also to many people who lived through those times, it was still almost heresy to suggest that we could ever have lost. Now that time has passed the subject can be examined more objectively. In summary I thoroughly recommend it - it is a frightening look at how things could have happened. Although the war took a terrible toll on Britain, this book serves as a reminder that it could have been far worse. War is often remembered through geography, in place names telling us where battles were fought and atrocities committed. Think how different it would feel today if those names had been on British soil.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A Chilling Might Have Been, 9 Jan 2005
This review is from: If Britain Had Fallen (Paperback)
The basic principal behind this book is to explore what might have happened if the German army had invaded in 1940. The book is split into three parts, the first details the background of the situation as it was in the early summer and the plans the government was making to repel a potential invasion. We also see what preparations the Germans were making and how their plans shifted from an invasion along the East Coast to an invasion along the whole South Coast then down to the Essex/Kent coastal region. In the middle section we have the most speculative part of the book, covering the invasion itself. By the nature of the book, Mr. Longmate has the Germans winning a substantial victory, with the RAF destroyed and most of the Royal Navy home fleet sunk. When operation Sealion is brought up on the soc.hist.what-if newsgroup the concensus of opinion is that if it had been attempted it would have failed horribly. The Royal Family had fled to the Bahamas (not Canada - the Canadian government could not accept having their king actually in the same country and it wouldn't have gone down well with their powerful neighbour to the south). Despite Hitler's desire to take Churchill prisoner, Winnie and General Brooke went down fighting leaving no one to offer their surrender to the Germans. There is a rather stirring description of the Royal Family's retreat to exile, making one realise how much more patriotic the whole nation was then. Although hardly less speculative in the specific detail, the final section of the book looks at how Britain would have felt under Nazi rule based on what happened in other occupied countries, in particular the Channel Islands. Longmate also looks at the plans the Nazis actually had for this country if they really had invaded (we laugh at some of the petty details that European law kicks up now and then but the Nazis were equally detailed and they would not have worried as much about public opinion!). Longmate reckons that the Nazis would have had serious problems finding enough suitable Quislings to build a puppet government to the degree that they would have to impose some form of direct rule. Rather interestingly he reckons that such apparently obvious allies as Sir Oswald Mosely would have refused to co-operate with the invaders. Probably correctly, he suggests that the Empire on its own would not be powerful enough to retake Britain and that America's first target would be North Africa. He is hopeful that Britain would retain its basic nature even under a lengthy occupation. I have to wonder about this for the Germans would have had control of the education system for virtually a whole generation. Over all though, this is a thought provoking book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A chilling alternative history based on fact, 19 Feb 2007
This review is from: If Britain Had Fallen (Paperback)
This is an absorbing and chilling alternative history, a look at what Britain might have been like and how British people might have behaved if the Nazis had conquered the country. Its grounding in historical reality is what gives it an added edge - the first four chapters detail established historical events; only then does history change and fiction., albeit logically extrapolated, take over when the Nazis concentrate their firepower on destroying our radar stations and airbases rather than bombing our civilian cities, thereby removing the RAF from the equation. From then on, the Nazis have the upper hand, helped on by a dose of good fortune, and the Nazis conquer the south east and take London, Churchill bravely dying in a hail of bullets in the process. The remainder of the book details what might well have happened in an occupied Britain, based largely on what happened in the Channel Islands as the only part of the British Crown under enemy occupation (though with some differences to allow for the different sizes and populations, etc) and partly on what happened in other occupied countries. The result is a chilling depiction of what might have been, especially if the Nazis had carried out their threat to deport all British males between the ages of 17 and 45 (though it should be added they did not do this in any other occupied country, and only threatened to carry it out in the Channel Islands if the Islanders did not behave, instead deporting only those Islanders not born there). Well worth a read and very thought provoking; how thin are the margins between freedom and occupation - thank God for those radars and those pilots!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|