21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An exciting new fantasy, 7 Feb 2005
By A Customer
As fantasies go, I have to say I enjoyed this novel - it is certainly in the upper rungs of the genre. Perhaps it didn't rank among the greats, but it certainly entertained me consistently. One of the signs of a talented author is their ability to control several overlapping storylines and characters in a way that keeps you on your toes no matter which person's story you are reading at the time. I hated the end of every chapter when it meant that thread of the story was left hanging, while we delved into another, but again, I was reluctant to finish the next chapter, too. If I had to pick a fault in this book, it would be the character of the king. I assume Keyes intended him to be a good man who suffered from the faults of humanity, but I found myself unable to get over his disrespectful treatment of his wife, a good person, the reasons for which are never explained. I also found it slightly odd that he never actually speaks to his children, though they feature often in his thoughts. Though the impending-evil-doom story is slightly contrived, The Briar King himself is a wonderfully twisted creation of folktale and your typical fantasy-baddy, one of the best villainous concepts to come out recently, and I only wish he had a larger role in the novel. In saying this, I have yet to read the second in the series, a task I am thoroughly looking forward to. Put simply, not one to be missed by any serious fantasy addict like myself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
39 of 40 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
What a spiny fellow!, 2 Nov 2004
This review is from: The Briar King (Kingdoms of Thorn and Bone) (Hardcover)
I bought The Briar King, by Greg Keyes, a while back because everybody told me that it was so good. However, I found myself reluctant to start yet another epic fantasy series, so it languished in my "To be read" stack. Then, I received a review copy of the second book in the series, The Charnal Prince, so I decided I should probably read both of them soon. I tell you this not because you should necessarily care what I do (what a man reads is really his private business unless he writes reviews about them), but so that you can avoid doing the same thing I did. If you like fantasy at all, you should go out, get this book, and maybe even the second book, and read them. Right now. Go ahead. I'll wait.
Oh, you want me to tell you why you should read it? Ok. Keyes has created a masterpiece with vivid characters, an interesting overarching plot, and a doom from the dawn of time. This is not your ordinary doom from the dawn of time, though. The Briar King is a force of nature that is never truly understood, something that's called forth to wreak havoc on the land, changing this world into its own gruesome image. With this book, Keyes is well on his way to reshaping that world. We follow a disparate group of characters, including a king, his queen, a young knight who becomes her protector, a couple of princesses, and a fencer who becomes infatuated with one of those princesses. On the other hand, we have the guardian of the King's Forest, his lover, and a monk who finds himself translating some very ancient, and very evil, documents, much to the detriment of the world, not to mention his own skin. A conspiracy is afoot throughout the land, one which may bring down an entire royal family, and one which may result in the death of everybody. Everywhere. Treachery abounds, and nobody is safe. Will the coming of the Briar King make this all moot?
Keyes does almost everything right in The Briar King. He switches settings with a deftness I haven't seen in quite a while, leaving each scene just when it's starting to get good. This causes the reader to read the traditional "just one more chapter" to find out what's going on. I average about one hundred pages a day usually, and I know I at least doubled that with this book. Every character is completely three dimensional, with the exception of Fend, one of the villains of the piece. I found him a bit flat, but otherwise, all of the characters are interesting. Keyes also takes the story in some unexpected directions. A love affair that seems very predictable doesn't, in fact, happen. There are some daring escapes, but each one is plausible, not stretching that oh-so-important suspension of disbelief that some fantasy novels break constantly. Each character has a completely understandable motivation that keeps the book moving at a lightning pace.
Keyes also does a wonderful job of world-building. The map is beautiful (he credits Kirk Caldwell for it) and the land is populated with a dazzling array of cultures, all of them suitably human but different enough that you can tell the difference. One area, Vitellio, is clearly patterned after medieval Italy, even down to the names which sound pseudo-Italian. This has the double benefit of giving you an idea what the culture is like but it's just different enough. He also has a talent for languages. The language in Vitellio is one example, but others have been made up as well. He even goes so far as to invent dialects and slang for some of the people.
Finally, I have to compliment Keyes on the prose in the book. The imagery is amazing and the action scenes are extremely well choreographed. They are realistic, and blood does flow vividly, but he's not so graphic that heads are bouncing all over the place (though one or two of them do). Whether it's a quiet scene or a loud scene with swords bouncing off of plate armour, Keyes does a great job with it. Here's an example:
"Asper White opened his eyes to a vaulted stone ceiling and a distant, singsong litany. Fever crawled like centipedes beneath his skin, and when he tried to move, his limbs felt like rotting fern fronds." Pg 382
Best of all, Keyes is not afraid to kill any of his characters. Some people think that George R.R. Martin is sadistic to his characters! The body count is quite high, but none of the deaths are gratuitous. Each one fits the story perfectly, though some are quite perfunctory. Even these, however, don't feel out of place. Instead, they are realistic. While there are heroic escapes (and, admittedly, a couple of rather unrealistic ones), it's never a certainty that the viewpoint character will make it out of the scene alive. Sometimes, a death is just a death.
The Briar King is one of the best fantasy books I've read since Jennifer Fallon's series, and I think it even surpasses them. Everything just comes together in a rich whole, making a juicy treat that will taste good with every bite. And the best thing is, when you finish it, you can pick up the second book and wolf that one down too. Sadly, it will be close to a year before the final book is out.
David Roy
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A compelling start, 6 Dec 2004
The Briar King is the first volume in The Kingdoms of Thorn and Bone series. It is a multi-threaded novel following several groups of characters, each with their own mini-adventures. In most fantasy novels, the focus is on a main hero but in this book - rather like Geroge R. R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire sequence - we follow the fate of several characters, never quite knowing how their destinies are connected.
There's one thing for sure, however. Greg Keyes shows great skill in jumping from scene to scene and ending each chapter with a cliffhanger. Seldom is there a dull moment as every chapter is filled to the brim with action and fresh developments to keep readers at the edge of their seats. Numerous sword fights, boy-meets-girl encounters, political intrigues, and man vs. monsters matches keep the page turning.
Keyes succeeds in creating characters that you get to care about: a royal forester, a rebellious princess, a naieve priest, a young man who is suddently turned into the queen's protector, and a roguish adventurer to name but a few. You are advised not to get too attached to any of them, however, as the author does not hesitate to kill his characters whenever the plot dictates.
If you're on the lookout for another fantasy series to get your teeth into while waiting for the next Martin or Jordan novel, give this a go. The Briar King grips from the first chapter and never lets go. The final chapter ties up just enough loose ends to satisfy those expecting a conclusion but it also makes promises of even greater things to come.
Review by Antonio Pineda
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No