This Breville has a solid motor unit, a useful assortment of blades, can store all the bits within itself, and has the bonus of a very handy separate blender jug, giving this the potential of being an extremely desirable kitchen tool.
The ergonomics of using it and the various featured cutters are reasonable, noticeably better than some similar machines I have used in recent years.
BUT, I have a few quibbles. The first three are major, and the fourth is a possible Safety issue.
1. It is much too noisy.
The gears grinding away all the time are a pain on the ear. It is even noisier than the similarly arranged
Jamie Oliver Food Processor I tested two years ago. Owww...
2. (Added 2/1/2012) There is a major design flaw with the Blender jug. The safety interlock tabs are fragile and easily knocked off when fitting it onto the base unit; end of jug. They could easily have made the interlock as part of the bayonet fixing instead of this silly tab system. This definitely loses it another star.
3. The "Intelligent" speed control is a stupid joke, especially when compared with other less "Intelligent" machines such as this
Philips Food Processor.
All the buttons work for both attachments, so why bother labelling one set for Blender and one set for Processor?
All the speeds are too fast, and there is no useful difference between any of the speeds offered on the four buttons for the Blender, or the four buttons offered for the Processor, except going from Fast, to Faster Still, to Far Too Blinding Fast.
The remaining four buttons for `Pulse', `+', `-`, Stop are also no improvement, since it always starts Fast and the `-` then has to be used to reduce the speed, by which time the damage has been done, and even then the speed hunts up and down.
The high speed of the machine on anything but Pulse means that almost everything is reduced to a pulp, regardless of which blade or cutter is selected.
I find it daft that the Pulse button is the only simple way to run it more slowly.
4. There is no safety interlock with the Jug lid, so it is possible for a
Darwin Award candidate to explore the moving parts or to be splashed with hot liquids.
5. I miss having a dedicated blunt dough blade, the slicer simply destroys it. My old
Morphy Richards Compact Food Processor fares much better here.
Many Good Points.
1. The Processor bowl is has both handle and filler at the front. This is excellent since one doesn't use both at the same time and it does not matter if the user is left or right handed. Simply pull it towards the centre front to lock it in place - nice and intuitive for a right hander. And the lack of any ribs on the bowl means it is easy to extract the last bits of food.
2. The lid is secured in the same way and has a rubber seal to prevent spillage when whisking up liquids such as soup. Note that the rubber seal on the lid makes it very difficult to fit when dry, fortunately this operation becomes very easy when the mating surfaces are lubricated with some water or cooking oil.
3. The two slicer/grater discs each have a different face for the other way up, allowing four coarsenesses of destruction of the food. If the machine was slower one might be able to distinguish between the results!
4. The adjustable Julienne cutter is a very neat idea, shame about the high speeds.
5. The emulsifying disc produces silky smooth mayonnaise and cheese sauces. Speed is good here.
6. The general purpose slicer blade is highly effective and reduces everything to a fine shred in brief instants. It reaches close to the sides of the bowl, and close to the bottom, so not much food will escape its fate. Again the excessive speed is the only problem.
7. The safety interlock on the bowl and lid is ingenious and works well. There is no chance of losing bits of fingers or being splashed with boiling hot liquids.
8. The blender Jug is excellent in use when the lid is secure, and is easy to clean, even though it cannot be dismantled.
9. There is a handy storage drawer on the base of the motor unit where the two disc tools are kept, and the remaining parts store neatly in the bowl. In a cluttered or bijou kitchen this is a very welcome bonus. But this makes the unit tall, and it just touches the bottom of our wall cupboards.
10. All the components (apart from the motor unit, of course) can be (apparently) washed safely in a dishwasher. But I think the Jug handle and the interlock mechanism channel in the Bowl might collect dishwasher sediment, so we wash those units by hand.
Summary.
This could have been a brilliant processor; all the tools are nice and well thought out, really ergonomic, but it loses at least one star for the ridiculously high speed and excessive noise, and I've down-rated it another star because of the very poor jug design.
I would have liked a proper variable speed control, after all, if my electric drill can have one, then why not a food processor? As an electronic design engineer I'm tempted to consider putting in my own control circuit, but that will have to wait until the warranty expires.
.
Addendum 1. 11 April 2012
Jug failure.
Both of the safety-interlock tabs beneath the jug have snapped off. This is a fault of design/manufacture: ie, if it had been made of polycarbonate it would not have been brittle enough to snap; conversely, if it had been designed with the cheaper plastic in mind the tabs should have been much thicker to resist the inevitable accidental damage.
The Breville support people were very friendly and helpful, but I said for them not to send me another jug from existing stock because it would fail again in a few more months. Rather, they should fix the problem first.
I have bodged it on the one side by clamping a small bit of folded 1mm thick aluminium sheet to one of the ribs to form a makeshift replacement tab.