Eileen MacKenny's life story is authentic, awful, funny, outrageous and a bloody good read. An account of London criminal subculture across 80 years, much of the book seems like an account of the nineteenth not twentieth century. A slight book really but a page-turner nevertheless., written against the odds. Her dedication is "to all those people who didn't believe I could do it or was talking rubbish - I told you so!" She certainly did. I finished BORSTAL GIRL in one sitting, even if at times I found myself a bit aghast at the descriptions of violence and brutality Eileen lived through in South London, and worse delivered to other women.
BORSTAL GIRL describes Eileen's life as a street fighter, shoplifter, fraudster, thief, causal worker, scam artist, jump up accomplice, fence, and above all Mother of four, and grandmother who did it all (in her mind at least) to survive with her family the best way she " knew, fucking, how". Life with Eileen's violent brothers, before and after she lost her mum during the last year of the war, meant she never stopped fighting. She says, it was fighting her corner that helped her survive through harsh and at times cruel treatment dished out to the poor during the war, evacuation, the land army, borstal, and South London criminal sub culture where she lived for a bit with Big H MacKenny, the love of her life. He was wrongly convicted of murder in 1980, having earlier abandoned her and their kids. Yet she takes responsibility for the failure of that relationship, and when the shit hits the fan, is there standing by her man during his worse hour. There is no easy stereotypical script here either, as his rejection of her remains constant , and her account of her obsessive loyalty to him, she acknowledges, brings further trouble to their doors.
Yet Eileen doesn't engage in self pity and often her account is funny perhaps because her story exhibits the sort of gallows humour familiar in the biographies of many life long criminals. Having taken down and published the life story of Shirley Pitts, "Queen of Thieves", I recognize the power and authenticity of the speaking voice and unique descriptions of a real life lived. Eileen , was a woman from a well known family, who made her living from crime, and paid the price for being labeled "deviant" and who I had not heard much about, even from Shirley. who knew her, until I read this book.
At 80, looking back on her London Life Eileen confesses few regrets. She says even today she "still can't be told what to do, or more than I ever could, and I don't take kindly to piss taking". Me too! Her stories reveal true spirit and also the fine line between frustration, non-conformity and potential mental illness. Just pray the next generation of MacKenny women find feminism and different and more creative ways to express such fighting spirit . There is female force here to be reckoned with and admired - if not emulated ...
LORRAINE GAMMAN