"Surreal & densely textured, the novel is about choices that shape one's life. The language demands attention to itself for its studied efforts at beauty. First rate."
"A comedy of manners with a prose style that veers between deadpan and florid metaphors, which doesn't quite make up for the lack of plot. Work of an erudite writer who has nothing much to write about."
"The latest novel from the ‘master of misery’ is a grim, chilly tale. The prose is flawless, but the story, after its dramatic opening, loses momentum as Coetzee starts spouting postmodernist ideas."
"A literary whodunit, pullulating with caricaturusque historical characters, with liberal dollops of kindergarten psychology, and preposterous ending. It’s all silly, but it’s an easy read."
"A heart-warming, dryly comic story of a young Black girl of Jamaican parents, growing up in the 80s’ Britain, finding her roots. The second part, set in Jamaica, is a tad unconvincing."
"Story of an English middle class family unravelling in the face of a crisis. Brilliant in patches, but the tone of the narrative is uneven. A good book, but that’s about it."
"Boyd tries a new genre and nearly pulls it off. Not in the same league as a vintage Le Care or Deighton, it's an entertaining if light weight offering from one of my favourite authors."
"This gothic tale has it all: murder; incest; suicide; insanity; histories of the Fens, land reclamation, and river Ouse; nature of phlegm; and a discourse on the sex lives of eels!"
"Unabashedly derivative in its plot structure and development, and pivotal characters (to Howards End), it’s nevertheless an easy and entertaining read thanks to Smith’s flowing, witty prose."
"An epic, endearing and tragic-comic tale of friendship which is also a fascinating account of the dawn of the American comics industry. The rich, gorgeous, lyrical prose adds to the reader’s pleasure."
"Reads more like a long religious essay than a novel, with overproduced, self-enamoured sentences. Unless you are a believing Christian with fundamentalist leanings, give this novel a miss."
"A smarmy piffle, which exaggerates every Galic foible and plays up all the stereotypes of the French to the hilt. Mildly amusing at times, and the prose flows smoothly. A book to read in the loo."
"The delicate story of a love affair between an adolescent and a slightly older, married woman. The style is so assured that it’s difficult to believe that Radiguet was only 17 when he wrote it."
"The novel explores the life of its protagonist in 3 parts, told by 3 different persons, with their own perspectives & limitations. The prose is mesmerizing. Worth a read."
"This cheerful novel is to be enjoyed in the context of its times: upper middle class English in the second decade of the 19th century. Brilliantly written, sharply observed, and very funny in parts."
"A comedy of manners which, despite some excellent passages, never quite hits the right note. Plot is unconvincing & characters lack depth, and you couldn't care less what happens to them."