"McEwan's first-rate writing is impressive but the plot is quite average that I'm afraid it's not the type of book that would linger on in my mind for long."
"Sophie Kinsella has become famous because of the shopaholic series, but I always like her other works much more, such as 'can you keep a secret', 'the undomestic goddess', and this one."
"This is my first Marian Keyes. I did expect myself to laugh my head off but it is not that funny because it deals with grief and loss. I still like it though."
"I was tempted to give it up when I was around 100 pages into the book . Lucky that I didn't. It emerges to be a moving tale of people struggling to pursue their own happiness. Good work."
"A real page-turner, though the twist isn't unexpected. A good choice for leisure reading. Despite some occasional awkward writings and boring scenes, I have enjoyed it."
"It's OK-ish. The beginning is good but the book starts to drag on in the middle. I had expected more from it and I don't think it lives up to the hype."
"The problem lies in the plot and characterisation. The two main characters are unlikeable (my opinion). I simply don't care what's going to happen to them. Completely forgetful."
"Of all chick-lit queens, she's still my favourite. This is a hilarious while at the same time moving book. At one point, you might shed a tear and the next moment, you're laughing your head off!"
"A love story at the backdrop of World War 2 in Hong Kong, but it is neither successful as a haunting war story nor a moving love tale. That leaves me unsatisfied. I had expected more."
"It is a funny read, light in tone, with comic characters; but the subject matter is heavy deep down: the predicaments of immigrants, the plights of world war, the haunting memories ..."