Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Stars are not appropriate for judging this book.,, 20 Oct 2002
This review is from: The Bondwoman's Narrative (Virago Modern Classics) (Paperback)
The Bondwoman's Narrative is an historical artifact, a significant contribution to the literature of the pre-Civil War United States and, most especially, to African-American history and culture. Rating such a relic as if it were a modern publication denies it the accord it deserves as a newly discovered record of the misery endured by humans who were bought and sold in the last years of slavery. Telling the story of Hannah Crafts, a literate house slave, the author, convincingly identified by editor Gates as a black woman, pens a sentimental melodrama, a genre popular at the time, to describe in detail the life of a slave. Leading a somewhat less miserable life than a field hand, Hannah reveals her never-ending duties, her treatment and mistreatment by wives of the owners, her observations on the sexual abuse of women by owners, and her firsthand knowledge of venal slave traders and unscrupulous lawyers. These accounts are remarkable for their immediacy and human drama. The novel's narrative flow, as one traumatic episode after another builds to a climax, is clearly planned. Characters from one part of the novel appear and reappear in other parts, and sentimental motifs, common to the genre, repeat--the personification of a linden tree which affects several generations, curses visited on people and carried out over time, coincidences which strain credibility, and the hand of providence helping the pious Hannah. Although Gates's arguments for black authorship are convincing, he does not address some intriguing European references here. Fresh linens look like "an alpine snowdrift," Mr. Wheeler is noted by Hannah as having "the attitude of a Frenchman," Mrs. Wheeler says she will not accept Hannah's "blarney," Hannah refers to the poetry of Lord Byron, and she describes Mrs. Wheeler in one scene as having "the rage of Orestes." These struck me as unusual metaphors and references, and I'd be intrigued to learn how common they were to the day and how and why Hannah came to employ them. Mary Whipple
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Beautiful Learning Experience, 5 Mar 2003
I couldn't have been more moved or impressed with a work of literature than I was with "The Bondwoman's Narrative" by Hannah Crafts and Henry Louis Gates Jr (Editor). Sadly, this is a part of history and literature that I am not that familiar with so I was eager to read this and expand my horizons and knowledge base. WOW! I was taken back in time to a world that I can hardly imagine. As a 27 year old white woman living in 2002 I can't even begin to truly understand what it meant to be a black slave in the South. It is a completely different world and existence that I will never comprehend. The mere fact that she was a self-educated woman who survived to reach freedom should be enough to make this a wonderful work but, it's so much more. It's the human condition and spirit that takes the reader on an adventure with Ms. Crafts. I was charmed. I found the Introduction by Mr. Gates particularly informative and was entranced by his ease and clear explanations. It is truly amazing how he found this unknown jewel. I am so glad that he did, because it provided me with knowledge that I desperately needed. Thank you!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
44 of 44 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A LANDMARK MEMOIR, 21 April 2002
By Gail Cooke - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Bondwoman's Narrative (Hardcover)
It is one thing to read about the injustices of slavery from a historical or even an observer's point of view. It is quite something else to learn of the daily life of a slave in the indentured person's own voice. Such is the case with "The Bondwoman's Narrative" penned by a female slave in the 1850s. According to the editor this manuscript has existed for 140 years, and is quite probably the "earliest known novel by a female African-American slave and the earliest known novel by a black woman anywhere." Also according to Mr. Gates a slave escaped from a North Carolina plantation in 1857 and was able to reach New Jersey. It is his contention that she is the author of this book. Whether one wishes to question the authenticity of his identification or not is quite immaterial considering the compelling material within "The Bondwoman's Narrative." The relationship between ladies' maids and their mistresses is revealed in sharp detail, as are the offensive overtures by a relentless master. The slave and narrator is presented not as a human being but as chattel, valued only for what she might bring on the block. Ms. Craft has ably evoked pictures of the old South as well as the horrific conditions imposed by bondage. It is a miracle that these people could even hope for freedom. It is a wonder that this manuscript was brought to light at last. - Gail Cooke
35 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Two Fascinating Narratives in One, 26 April 2002
By Connie Ann Kirk - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Bondwoman's Narrative (Hardcover)
The first story is one of discovery and authentication on the part of Henry Louis Gates, Jr.. This story will be fascinating to scholars and others interested in how original manuscripts are found and in the problems and procedures for authenticating them as artifacts as well as resolving other issues surrounding their authorship. This mystery story continues because Gates is on a mission in this section to find the "real" Hannah Crafts. I kept reading quickly, following his strains of research with almost as much excitement and suspense as I did in reading Hannah's narrative itself. Hannah mentions names that Gates traces back to real people, and he gradually uncovers dots, then connects them for the reader, showing just how exciting scholarship of this kind can be as a human endeavor. As an American literature scholar myself, I finished Gates's narrative wanting to run out and search for Hannah Crafts as well [if I only had the time and energy with all the other mysteries I'm already trying to solve]. The second narrative, of course, and really the most important, is Hannah Craft's novel itself, which is thought so far to be autobiographical, in which a first person narrator describes her experience as a house slave and her eventual escape from a plantation near Wilmington, NC, via the Underground Railroad to New Jersey. The novel is a quick read, like a popular novel today with traces of the 19th C. sentimental novels of its day, with suspense and Dickens-like characterizations. There is a noted motif of "passing" (as one race for another and one gender for another) that is fascinating to trace throughout the story. Perhaps the great "pass" of all is the unanswered question about the racial identity of the author, a question that bothers some greatly that it is even being asked and is critically important to others that it be answered as accurately as possible. Gates includes material that makes this version of the book "teachable" as well (he plans a later scholarly edition)--a listing of the library holdings Crafts is presumed to have had access to; passages from Dickens's BLEAK HOUSE set side by side with echoes from Crafts's novel; chapter notes by the editor that point to issues in similar narratives by Frederick Douglass and Harriet Jacobs, etc. Whether you eventually "buy" Gates's claims about its authenticity and importance or not, the book provides a focal point for discussions of many issues, both for the general reader and the specialist in American literature, American studies, history, gender studies, textual studies, and many others. It's also a peek inside the work of literary scholars, which reveals just how much fun our detective work (often thought to be dry and dusty by others) really is. I say, read it, and let the conversations, and thought-provoking arguments, begin! ~Prof. Connie Ann Kirk
26 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Unique and Unprecedented, 16 April 2002
By A Customer - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Bondwoman's Narrative (Hardcover)
"The Bondwoman's Narrative" is an unprecedented literary event. This manuscript, recently discovered by Professor Henry Louis Gates, Jr. is the only known novel to have been written by an African American slave. It might possibly be the first manuscript to have been written by a black woman...anywhere. Not only is the narrative unprecedented, it is a suspenseful and engrossing account of a young slave who "passes" for white in her attempt to find her way to freedom. The bondwoman is Hannah Crafts, a mulatto and a slave, who wrote her story as an autobiographical novel. Hannah Crafts was not uneducated, she was self-educated. And, as anyone familiar with world literature will realize, Hannah Crafts, may have been very well educated, indeed. As we read her story, written in an effusive style, we realize that she was well aware of the limitations and injustices society inflicted on persons of color in 19th century America. What she didn't realize is that the freedom and life of the plantation's mistress is soon to be in as much peril as is her own and that their destinies will intertwine. Is Hannah Crafts story an autobiographical rendition or is it a flight of fancy, albeit a very good flight of fancy? I think it is up to each individual reader to judge. "The Bondwoman's Narrative" really doesn't tell us anything new about the times in which Hannah Crafts lived. It's significance lies not in the facts it presents (although they are interesting), but in its historical value. The fact that this is, quite probably, the first narrative to have been written by a black woman makes "The Bondwoman's Narrative" unique and unprecedented and a true literary event. Almost as interesting as the story of Hannah, herself, is Professor Gates' introduction in which he details his own search for the real Hannah Crafts and the true facts of her life. Although the details in this book are details we have read before, perhaps several times before, we have not read them as presented by Hannah Crafts. The experience of slavery was important in shaping the character of America and, because of this importance, Hannah Crafts' voice is a voice that should be heard. I don't think anyone who reads this unique and sometimes very lovely book, will ever regret it.
|
|
|