2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Faded Eastern promise, 28 Sep 2007
This review is from: Bombay Art Deco Architecture: A Visual Journey 1930-1953 (Hardcover)
Who would have thought that Bombay would have the largest concentration of Art Deco buildings outside of Miami Beach. There is a photo on pages 272-273 of Marine Drive, Bombay and you could be forgiven for thinking, at a quick glance, that this might be Ocean Drive, Miami. Navin Ramani reveals the background to this remarkable architectural heritage in the front of his book: the opening of the Suez Canal, a merchant class settling in Bombay, the city becomes the center of the Indian architectural profession and extensive land reclamation from 1929 all helped to create a unique Far Eastern Deco habitat.
The book's many photos show plenty of apartments and commercial buildings with their concrete curved lines, geometric floor patterns and streamlined appearance. It's unfortunate though that the photos also show plenty pipe-work and aircon units spoiling the external look of so many of them. It is the movie palaces that really show off the Deco style. The interiors of the five featured bubble over with streamline curves, recessed lighting and flamboyant marble floor patterns.
Ramani's book will surely be the definitive one about Bombay deco but I was rather disappointed with many of the author's photos. They lack a sharpness and the colour is rather muted and dull. I became aware of this when I compared them with Arnold Schwartzman's clean, focused photos of 'Deco LAndmarks: Art Deco Gems of Los Angeles' and in fact there is a good example of the photographic difference in Ramani's book on pages 256-257, on the left is a dull, flat photo of 63 Marine Drive, Bombay and the right a similar looking Hotel Victor in Miami but the photo is sharp, clean and colourful. Still, despite this Bombay Art Deco is certainly worth having if you love this exuberant architecture.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantastic insight into Mumbai's Art Deco heritage., 18 Mar 2010
This review is from: Bombay Art Deco Architecture: A Visual Journey 1930-1953 (Hardcover)
A handsome inspiring hardback for lovers & followers of Art Deco architecture. This book brings to life Mumbai's Art Deco architecture struggling to survive in a fast moving and changing 21st Century India. Mumbai (formerly Bombay) has the second largest collection of Art deco buildings after Miami and this publication is a good introduction to the Art Deco style of architecture in Mumbai from its inception from 1930 to its demise during the early 1950's. The book is well researched and well presented in a contemporary fashion with excellent illustrations and interpretations from residentail buildings to cinema halls. Lots of large wonderful colour photographs making it a stunning visual journey of Art Deco buildings still surviving to this very day with their respective locations. The author Navin Ramani passion for Art Deco & architecture is keenly reflected with his acknowledgements, his own collection of photographs and contributions from his family, friends & colleagues making this book a delight and excellent value for money. A short comparison between the architectural styles of Mumbai & Miami at the final chapters is very interesting. This book certainly does its part to raise awareness for maintaining, preserving & regenerating the Art Deco heritage architecture of a bygone era in Mumbai the same way it has done for Miami. A highly recommended buy...enjoy!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No