First the review: I found this a GREAT book documenting the trials and tribulations of training people who go into very high-tech fields. Though it describes the training of fighter pilots, it could as easily describe the making of surgeons or engineers. The same things that we see in medicine occur in this community: the sieve gets finer, the best get through it, and usually the unworthy don't. Tragedies can and do happen along the way--that happens in both fields as well--but in fighters, the loss is usually more personal than it is in medicine. What Gandt did was to bring enormous amounts of warmth and humor into the fray, and he managed not to be judgmental when he could easily have done so. It stands as one of the best books on or near the subject that I have read. META-REVIEW: Reading over the other reviews posted here is fascinating. All reviews are either raves or total pans, the former outnumbering the latter. Objections seem to be from the uninformed--or those who, for reasons of their own, want Gandt not to be correct. Alas, he is. But it remains a mark of a great book that it excites strong passions.