I have followed 'New Frontier' since I read book 1 when I got given a free copy with the old Star Trek Magazines I used to buy. I read it, thought id try books 2 and 3, and by the time the original 4-part series had finished, it had captivated me with its use of familiar secondary characters and an interesting new captain and ship.
Over the years ive always been highly excited on a new 'New Frontier' novel on the shelfs.. in a way its Star Trek for people who love Star Trek but want that edge to the show that a TV series could never provide.. a theoretical world where a Captain could do what he wants when he wants and for-go the consequences.
The events around the time of book 8 that lead into the 3-part 'Excalibur' trilogy was an exciting wait for me, and even the books after that was an interesting read.
Nowadays, I want to still be excited by a New Frontier novel, a small part of it is still there, but there really does feel something gone now. In a small way I think its just the passage of time and getting older - the New Frontier novels have always been excellent about 'changes' more akin to real life changes (ie people aren't going to be the same as they were 10 years ago), but the writing style is still there.
So, pro's and cons in my view :- It's still New Frontier, and Peter David is still out to see a story that engages as many of the characters he's created over the years and bring out character traits we recognize and new directions from the all. Thats great. However their initial mission in Thallonian space has come to an end and now they are just getting caught up in something or other rather randomly. Maybe this is unavoidable story-wise but has a slight aimless feel to it.
Captain Calhoun is a great creation - however, is anybody else just a tad tired of reading how he is practically 'super-human' in every endeavour? I think this is a Peter David trait, as in alot of story points, where the reader can pick up on what he is trying to say, David has a habbit of over-explaining the point just so the reader is definately aware of what is being pointed out.
There also used to be the idea of a couple of novels per year, but now its one book every 2-3 years, probably because Peter David is wrapped up in many long running projects and trying to keep many fans happy, but now it seems like a one off return novel then a long running return series, and in some cases it really can be hard to remember what occured before. Also, it sounds a bit nit-picking, but the actual covers of the books themselves used to look alot more exciting - a ship, a character from the story - now we just have a starfleet badge on a planet?? Doesn't build up much excitement...
Im left at a point where I don't know if to say they need to wrap up New Frontier and leave the 15 years of memories as a great period, or keep it going for another 10 years and get a slight diluted excitement to each incoming novel, because I don't want to stop reading at the same time, or even suggest that another author gives it a go to see how it comes out.