Please note that this album features 18 tracks (not 16 as stated.) "Reason to Believe" and "Unforgiven" are included at the end.
Tim Hardin was one of the best singer-songwriters to emerge out of the folk-rock-blues scene of the early sixties. There was always an underlying feeling of sadness in most of his utterly compelling, melodic and deeply felt songs. Although his oeuvre is now largely ignored, it truly deserves, in my opinion, the same respect accorded to Nick Drake or Van Morrison, for instance.
This collection mainly focuses on his first two LP's released on Verve: seven tracks come from "Tim Hardin 1" (1966) while five come from "Tim Hardin 2" (1967.)
A great, live (?) version of "You Upset the Grace of Living When You Lie" comes from "Tim Hardin 3" (Verve, 1968.) I reviewed the latter album somewhere on this website.
Three songs originally appeared on the second CD of Tim Hardin's definitive "Hang on to a Dream: The Verve Recordings" (Polydor, 1994.)
"Danville Dame" is an outtake from "Tim Hardin 1" and it receives a much better interpretation on the "live" "Tim Hardin 3." "You Got a Reputation" obviously uses the same musicians (less John Sebastian); it is pleasant although it does not rank with the very best of Tim Hardin. "If I Knew" is a somewhat non-descript, early demo of a song that would appear, much more convincingly, on "Bird on a Wire" (Columbia, 1971.)
The last selection is the title track of the last studio album that Tim Hardin worked on at the time of his death on December 29, 1980. It harks back to the material on the first two Verve albums. This is not the original version, but one overdubbed with useless back-up vocals.
My criticism is twofold.
First, this collection presents an unbalanced view of Tim Hardin's Verve recordings. It completely eschews the rockier material in Tim's early repertoire (like "Green Rocky Road" or "How Long.") The only tracks representing this aspect of Tim Hardin's work are two of the aforementioned outtakes (tracks 10 and 11.)
Although it emphasizes Tim Hardin's softer, folk-rock side, it manages to "forget" one of Tim's best songs, namely "If I Were a Carpenter." This is an incredible omission as this track is also Tim's best-known composition thanks to hit covers by the like of Bobby Darin (pop #8, 1966), the Four Tops, etc.
If you wish to buy a single disc compilation, the 15-track "Reason to Believe (The Best Of)" (Polydor, 1990) is a better buy (although the sound quality is not quite as good.)
Repertoire Records' "Tim Hardin 1 & 2" CD, which included all the material from his two first studio albums, was the way to go. This CD is, unfortunately, out of print.
Personally, I use the first CD from "Hang on to a Dream: The Verve Recordings" to listen to this material. This 2-CD set, which comes in beautifully remastered sound, is available from Amazon.