I haven't bought any other similar products in order to be able to compare, but this one suits me just fine and I don't think I will need to change it. I use it for my iPhone 3G, to which it fits perfectly! It leaves the appropriate space for the buttons and the camera, and I also find it very stylistic, although this is rather a personal point of view. The only negative comment I would make would be that it messed a bit with my screen-protector in one of its edges, while trying to remove it, but you could say that I could have been a bit more careful. In my opinion, good value for money!