I loved The Houdini Girl and Exit Orange and Red but was a little disappointed by Black Cat. The central character, Chloe is a little too similar to Rosa - the Houdini girl. They are both beautiful, compelling, complex young women, outsiders from mainstream society, independent, transient, and emotionally damaged in ways that are gradually revealed. Both have the same talent for smart one liners. The books also have similar structures, interspersing written sources, newspaper reports, transcripts of interviews with characters, legal submissions, into the narrative to expand on things already hinted at, or give a teaser for those to come. The parallels between the habitually black dressed Chloe and the eponymous cat are rather obviously drawn - both finding a home in an alien environment, both the object of unhealthy obsession. However, while the story of Houdini made for a suspenseful thriller, Black Cat's story is much thinner. That said, the writing is very sharp, particularly the dialogue and descriptions of the moorland settings, and all the main characters are well drawn. But read Houdini Girl first.