Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great Le Guin short story collection, 17 Jul 2002
This collection of short stories by Ursula K. Le Guin shows her strength as an author and worldbuilder. Some (not all) of the stories take place on worlds of the Ekumen or Hainish universe. One of the stories is brand new, the others have been published in various magazines.We visit worlds like Gethen, as in the novel 'The Left Hand of Darkness', where most individuals are neither female nor male, but periodically enter the state of kemmer, where they asume one or the other sexual form. Or O, where couples marry couples. On the planet Seggri women outnumber men, who are kept apart for enjoyment and recreation purposes. In the short story 'Solitude' we visit a planet where there is no society as such, just loose bonds and encounters. Of course, such short summaries can't get across the detail of Le Guin's work. And it is precisely the social anthropology and the details that make the stories and the worlds very much alive - and make you think. For the stories are not only thought-provoking, they might even be plain provoking, and may make you think again on several subjects. So for a collection of science fiction in which there is more social science than physics or chemistry, 'The Birthday of the World: and other stories' is a very fine choice.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Very strong set of stories, 9 Nov 2003
This is a set of speculations about possible societies, distinguished by having different conventions for sexual and gender relations. With this subject there is danger of an author using characters as too-obvious puppets, but no ax-grinding here, all the stories are personal narratives, with a wide variation in viewpoint and tone, and more to the point very well written, readable, and interesting. Good speculative fiction. All within a faint background of LeGuins Hainish/Ekumen novels. I had thought it would be a late-career roundup or ragbag of stories, but it's much more of a integrated themed work, and a bit of a tour de force.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Very strong set of stories, 9 Nov 2003
This as a set of speculations about possible societies, distinguished by having different conventions for sexual and gender relations. With this subject there is danger of an author using characters as too-obvious puppets, but no ax-grinding here, all the stories are personal narratives, with a wide variation in viewpoint and tone, and more to the point very well written, readable, and interesting. Good speculative fiction. All within a faint background of LeGuins Hainish/Ekumen novels. I had thought it would be a late-career roundup or ragbag of stories, but it's much more of a integrated themed work, and a bit of a tour de force.
|
|
|
|