I LOVED Gods in Alabama, her first book. I ordered this straight away afterwards, but only got around to reading it now... and I'm afraid it's now calling the charity shop home.
It's about a woman named Nonny, from tiny Between in Georgia, who is by birth one of the feckless, trashy Crabtrees but raised as an order-loving and proud Frett. Now aged 30, she's divorcing her faithless husband Jonno but can't stop falling into bed with him. Back in Between, her deaf and blind adoptive mother needs her, as does a young relative, Fisher. And Bernese, the hard-to-like Frett family matriarch, has just kicked off a family war with the Crabtrees. So Nonny's torn between the city and her hometown, the Crabtrees and the Fretts, Jonno and a potential new love interest...
It's hard to explain, but not one of the characters did it for me. In Gods in Alabama, which had similar themes of a girl coming home from the city to her dysfunctional Southern family, I loved Lena and her boyfriend from the start, and grew to love cousin Clarice and Lena's strict Aunt Florence. I thought the characterisation in that book was awesome, and there was a lot of humour in it too. Not to mention the pace was snappy and the plot very cleverly put together. These qualities were sorely lacking for me in Between, Georgia. Perhaps it needed a good mystery like G. in A. had, because the only real suspense in the plot was whether Nonny would divorce Jonno. Apart from that, it was more of a vague "how will things turn out?". The characters were all idiosyncratic but they just didn't touch my heart, and I didn't really care exactly how things turned out for them. Maybe they lacked depth. Bernese, for example, had a similar role to Aunt Florence in G. in A., but while Aunt Florence is first presented as a complete cow and slowly revealed to have many layers, Bernese never seemed to develop in a similarly satisfying way (although there is a nice twist concerning her!). I still thought she was a cow at the end. And Nonny herself was a bit of a non-starter for me, too.
Overall, I would have liked to have seen less kookiness, more action and motivation, and more on the relationships between the characters. The book just seemed to bumble along almost as if she was half making it up as she went along; it read more like a draft than a finished and edited novel.
Still, I'm sure there is better to come from the talented Joshilyn Jackson and I will still look out for her books in the future. Gods in Alabama shows how good she can be. Between, Georgia doesn't hold a candle to it in my opinion, though it looks like I'm in the minority.