This compilation of the Island Years, was put together by Tom himself, but excludes a few of his finest recordings from that time. There's no 'In The Neighbourhood', arguably his finest and most memorable recording from the Island period, no 'Soldier's Things', undoubtedly his best song from the period, and no 'Raindogs', one of his finest left field recordings of the period. It leads one to question whether an artist should compile their own work. It's hard to understand the inclusion of a piece as lightweight as Temptation, with the comical Prince falsetto. It would have been nice to have had 'A Little Rain' or 'Whistle Down The Wind' from Bone Machine, or the incredibly touching, 'The Briar And The Rose' from The Black Rider. If one judges what actually is included, then it's utterly brilliant, but it's not a worthwhile buy for committed Waits fans. All the recordings have been heard before, so there's really no incentive for that constituency. As an introduction to the Island period, without the three pieces mentioned, it feels badly incomplete. For me, 'In The Neighbourhood' was the gateway into the new Waits, so without it, there's a sense of being plunged unaware into the oeuvre if one is just discovering the genius of Waits. On the plus side, there's the beautiful 'November', the incomparable avant garde stomp of 'Singapore', his second best song from the period, 'Time', the superb Beefheartian howl of 'Earth Died Screaming', the skewed blues of '16 Shells', the tender sophistication of 'Johnsburg Illinois', the dark Germanic fun of 'The Black Rider', the superb rhythmic tightness of 'Jockey Full Of Bourbon', and the wonderfully atmospheric 'Shore Leave'. For the uninitiated it's a worthwhile purchase, though there's no substitute for owning at least the first three Waits albums on Island (Swordfishtrombones, Rain Dogs and Frank's Wild Years, together constituting the most adventurous and visionary music of the eighties). Swordfishtrombones is always the first port of call, as it broke the mould completely, and laid the visionary path he would continue to follow for the subsequent twenty years.